Point Reconsideration proposal.

Contributor: PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
No-nita, the official request form will be posted tomorrow.
Though I feel confident in my own contributions, that doesn't mean you won't instantly remove my points because I went through a suspension a couple months ago. You clearly stated in your first message that those of us who have been through a suspension would not be allowed to get our points back.

So, feeling secure in my own actions or not, how am I to know that you're not going to instantly remove them for that simple fact?
06/23/2013
Contributor: 223344 223344
How "Fred like" to come to this conclusion. It also reeks of Stormy. This is an "attempt" to make him look good and look as if he cares, which by now if you cannot CLEARLY see that he doesn't, you're just as big of a dipshit as he is. He'll give us our points, but we have to pass a ridiculous check list and if at ANY time you've done ONE of the things mentioned, well he's gonna say fuck you. ALL of us have done one or more of those mentioned things, so we're all screwed.
Face the music people, we aren't getting our points. Take your losses. Contact Firey Red and join the rest of us in our own little forum and learn where else to go spend your time at. There's no drama over there and no huge douche bag to set ridiculous standards. You're free to express yourself and you don't need to kiss anyone's ass over there.
Fred's terms are bullshit. No other way to put it.
  •   (1)
    This is unacceptable / Against the Expectations of Conduct
06/23/2013
Contributor: js250 js250
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
This can be a legit activity, but we will look into details. I personally don't know anyone who can regularly submit 2 QUALITY reviews per day! Who is this person? A professional toy tester? If these QUALITY reviews were fiction, not a factual ... more
I have written 515 high quality, useful and educational reviews for Eden in the last 2 years and 22 days. All but a couple of the items were purchased from EF either in points, as an assignment or with cash. I have placed 130 orders in 24.75 months. I own another 106 items I have not reviewed as of this time. I have had 98 classes as a mentor, written 18 articles for Sexis, been the top ranked member of the whole site for a couple months and in the top 4 since then. I regularly go well over any of the low allotments on 'point' tasks and I have been a loyal and very supportive member of Eden--above and beyond being a basic member.

I can write 1-3 Sexis articles, 5 high quality, useful and educational reviews, AND participate on the site, mentor my students, run my retail business and do the work on my other two computer businesses daily with no problem. I am a very productive, eloquent and highly educated woman who budgets her time wisely. (And after purchasing, using and reviewing over 500 products from YOUR business--yes, I am a professional reviewer. Wouldn't you think so? After all, it is fully documented here on Eden.) And no, we have never been introduced, so you would not know me.

I will put my points and ability to be a member here to the test and will be the first one to accept your proposal. On a one to one basis-I only answer for myself, not the rest of the community. I figured that since I have 515 items you will need to pair with my reviews, it may take a bit of time to research and read them all. (Please excuse the pictures of the items included on the reviews, I am not a professional photographer, neither is my husband-he had to take the lingerie pictures.)

It is nice to finally get to met the owner of this site and I do hope you can bend a bit and work with the members who are here and trying to help you rebuild the integrity and trust back up. As a fellow business owner I realize how much time is taken up with the analyticals, P&L financials, diversifying and trimming components and aspects of a business to make it viable--I do this weekly and monthly as well.
06/23/2013
Contributor: snowminx snowminx
Quote:
Originally posted by PropertyOfPotter
Though I feel confident in my own contributions, that doesn't mean you won't instantly remove my points because I went through a suspension a couple months ago. You clearly stated in your first message that those of us who have been through a ... more
Point earning on eden- The ultimate catch 22

Out if you don't don't submit one and out when he switches up the rules again to show everyone is a point farmer.
06/23/2013
Contributor: SydneyScreams SydneyScreams
So I wasn't active for a few days and came back to all these shenanigans. I [naturally] have a few questions.

1-Who is doing the "judging" of who is a legit contributor or not? ie, I've only been on EF for a few months, but I'm trying to contribute whether points are given or not. My new status is understandably a reason to consider me not a legit contributor and I'm well aware of that...

2-Will there be fair, KNOWN guidelines for this judging?

3-Are you wanting picture verification that we own a product? Because that is fair...especially since once contributor that I've messaged Stormy about clearly doesn't seem to own any of the products they review...

4-What about items that we didn't purchase on EF? I have a slew of items in my "assignment cart" that were gifts from my fans...But I do actually own them.

What you're giving us, Fred, is a basic outline on how to make amends, but what you're not doing is giving the real information here. I want to contribute, but since I see everything going on, I'm weary to do so.

It seems unfair that you give us bare bones information... I know life isn't fair, but come on... Communicate!! We're all adults here...
06/23/2013
Contributor: gorgeous gorgeous
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
I am considering (no decision has been made yet) to restore points to the honest contributors. Would you say this is a fair deal or not?

You will be asked to submit a reconsideration request. It is optional. If you chose not to participate, ... more
I agree with parts of this and disagree with parts. Rating and commenting on reviews should not be considered point farming. If you think that some products are are nonsense for reviews that make those where reviews can not be written on them. Other forums that I have for gaming have a thread where you can play spam games but they dont count as forum posts. Maybe we could have a place to have our fun useless discussions and we dont get points for it. And if you would change the points for some it should be for all. Everyone should be treated the same.
06/23/2013
Contributor: GonetoLovehoney GonetoLovehoney
Woooow, I just saw a ton of posts get deleted. Way to not listen to our opinions, Fred.
06/23/2013
Contributor: mmrrtt mmrrtt
Quote:
Originally posted by GonetoLovehoney
Woooow, I just saw a ton of posts get deleted. Way to not listen to our opinions, Fred.
Yep, here at EdenFantasys, as long as it's deleted, it NEVER happened.
Anything that speaks the truth, calls him out or calls Stormy out will ultimately be deleted.
06/23/2013
Contributor: js250 js250
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
The point schedules was a responsibility of the previous management. One of the reason they were let go.
Amnesty week was well after the staff was terminated, and as the person ultimately responsible for your business--the decisions and responsibility for the site functions, activities and guidelines are yours. I really appreciated the opportunity, but would rather have had you give us a choice of earning those points or helping to cut the costs of the site to make it more viable and financially secure.

If we would have had an opportunity to make the choice--most of your members would have chosen to forego the points until Eden was more stable. As a matter of fact, there are a few that would have been happy to volunteer--free of charge or points to help you out. That is what communities do, we support each other and value what the other has to offer as a person.
06/23/2013
Contributor: pootpootpoot pootpootpoot
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
No need to worry. We understand different situations, different products.
That's a huge relief! I've been stressing out over that for a while. I probably won't submit myself as I have very few points in my account, but I'm glad other people won't have to worry!
06/23/2013
Contributor: js250 js250
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
This is a discussion, not an ultimatum. If the majority thinks - it is unfair, why would I do it anyway? There won't be THIS deal.

I am confident in my previous decision. What I am doing right now is finding the way to make amends with a ... more
Thank you for the discussion, please listen to some of our points so a compromise can be reached. There has been so much instability and half truths that the trust factor has been seriously damaged.

Maybe if you gave the members a chance to show you they are good people who honestly care about the site and are proud of their contributions, they would also give you the chance to show us that you can work with them and compromise for the good of the business.
06/23/2013
Contributor: Fred Petrenko Fred Petrenko
Quote:
Originally posted by GonetoLovehoney
Woooow, I just saw a ton of posts get deleted. Way to not listen to our opinions, Fred.
Yes, if you saw them you couldn't call them "our opinions".
06/23/2013
Contributor: PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
Yes, if you saw them you couldn't call them "our opinions".
Still hoping for an actual answer:

Though I feel confident in my own contributions, that doesn't mean you won't instantly remove my points because I went through a suspension a couple months ago. You clearly stated in your first message that those of us who have been through a suspension would not be allowed to get our points back.

So, feeling secure in my own actions or not, how am I to know that you're not going to instantly remove them for that simple fact?
06/23/2013
Contributor: snowminx snowminx
Quote:
Originally posted by js250
Amnesty week was well after the staff was terminated, and as the person ultimately responsible for your business--the decisions and responsibility for the site functions, activities and guidelines are yours. I really appreciated the opportunity, but ... more
I personally would have tried to help. As a college student, I might not have the most money but I would still have kept posting (without any points) just to keep traffic up in here. Making orders when I could and trying to use real money on at least shipping and not taking free toys if I knew that could help.

What I don't respect is being slapped in the face and being all called point farmers, lying to us, and then giving outrageous demands from things we can't change while you dangle the points we already earned over our heads.

I think we can all agree that Fred went at this all wrong, something he's notorious for, instead of just fessing up to the things he's done wrong and just ask for help from the community. It's a shame since this place had so much potential.
06/23/2013
Contributor: Fred Petrenko Fred Petrenko
Here is the Reconsideration Request Form.

Thank you everyone for participation.
I am closing this thread for now.
06/23/2013
Contributor: zj22 zj22
Would we still be allowed to submit and get our points if we had reviewed the free products? I know they certainly go over the 500 points mark as each review was worth 1,000 points at that time. Personally I did write reviews for the free promotional gifts because I felt it was only right that I give reviews on items I received. (After all didn't it make Eden look better and wasn't that the point of the promotions to begin with?) I don't necessarily want or need the points for these. However I also have points sitting in my account for 'legitimate' reviews and would like to get those back. Would Eden be willing to take off the points given and not used from free product reviews, and then give me back my other points to use? Surely I'm not the only one who reviewed the free products not to point farm but as my own genuine thank you to the company for its generosity at those times.
06/23/2013
Contributor: snowminx snowminx
Of course you're closing it when you want to, like always.

I don't see any name calling or abuse happen here, what's the reason for the close? I still have unanswered questions about this, where do I send them now?
06/23/2013
Contributor: Fred Petrenko Fred Petrenko
Quote:
Originally posted by zj22
Would we still be allowed to submit and get our points if we had reviewed the free products? I know they certainly go over the 500 points mark as each review was worth 1,000 points at that time. Personally I did write reviews for the free ... more
yes
06/23/2013
Contributor: PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
Quote:
Originally posted by Fred Petrenko
yes
please answer my question first...
06/23/2013
Contributor: Fred Petrenko Fred Petrenko
Quote:
Originally posted by PropertyOfPotter
please answer my question first...
I believe I did (under your repost).
06/23/2013