Really depends on the toy and how much I spent on it.

I think I just keep mine in the bottom of my toy stash baggy.

Mine usually end up at the bottom of my bag/storage if they don't quite hit the mark. If they're broken though, I just toss them in the trash.

I can't bring myself to throw it away. I'm kind of cheap like that

i leave them in my draw thinking one day I will love them!

Bottom of the box. You never know when my mood or preferences would change- I might like them alot more in the future.

I keep them.

bottom of drawer or trash

We keep them all. There aren't too many we buy without research and have very few that don't make it back into the cycle!

I keep all my toys, because I may not liked at that time, but I may have a day when I want to use something different depending on how my body is feeling.

So far, I've only had a couple toys I don't like. If it isn't something I can sterilize, I use a condom with it. Thus, pretty much every toy of mine is superbly clean. If I try something and don't like it (especially if you can sterilize it), I give it to a friend. I'd rather see it go to good use than to sit in my toy box, collecting dust.

in a box in the closet

I've still been trying to figure out what to do with a couple of toys that are just total junk. For now, they're stashed in a dirty old storage box, but I don't want to throw them out, but I will never ever touch them again. The only ones I've had that I absolutely cannot use no matter what is the Platinum edition butterfly kiss and the bendy rose thing. They were both just awful! I don't even see how the rose is even considered a sex toy. It's a fat, blunt rose bud that won't even fit inside like it's supposed to. It does nothing but take up space.

I hate that I've tried using the toys that I hate because I'm sure someone else could've done something with it like give it as a gag gift even though I'm positive no person would ever actually use the items. We just don't have space for crappy toys when the women here at EF collect so many. I only have about 7 or 8 but I still don't have space to devote to un-usable toys.

I think I'm going to end up throwing them out all together though. Only the un-usable toys of course! I'm a cheapie and I love recycling things into new items. I can turn any old piece of crap into something beautiful no matter what it is, but I've yet to figure out what I could turn sex toys into..

I keep my unloved toys in a "box of shame" and bring them out a few more times a couple of months down the road to see if my opinion changes. If it doesn't, they end up in the trash.

I usually keep my seldom used toys in one of the EF totes I got during the Atlanta move or some kind of similar bag, the rest reside in my two toy boxes (the Devine Playchest and the Lockable Sex Toy Case)

Even if the toy isn't liked though, it does go into the toy box and will be used eventually in some creative way (I.e. a vibrator a didn't like to much turned out to work wonders in anal pleasure.)

Umm, I have a male friend who seems to be turned on by the thought of taking the toys I've used but don't want anymore.

I put it with the rest of my toys and will make time for it eventually

Throw them out

They end up at the bottom of my drawer for a while. I will eventually try them out again and if I still dislike them I toss them.

no room for duds

It's very hard to throw out something. Mabye if you are not attached to it.. But still.. I had a hard time throwing out most of my useless/broken childhoode toys (not sex toys). I guess it would be same with the adult toys now

We'll keep it in the bottom of the drawer and only use it sparingly until we can get a better (similar) toy to replace it, at which time the unloved toy gets thrown out.