its just a stupid saying. I say it all the time. My wife does get pissed though when i accidentally say it around gay friends
What do you do when someone says, "that's so gay?"
08/04/2010
I tend to not say anything, if it's an adult. If it's a child I have influence over (eg - nephew/niece, future children) I would certainly take the time to explain that for many people that could be very offensive and even if not it's highly inappropriate.
08/04/2010
Quote:
Society strives to find more words to say the same thing. It's how language evolves. If we only said tired to mean tired, some fabulous words wouldn't exist. Sleepy, drowsy, worn out, exhausted, fatigued, sapped, shopworn, wearied. Ahhh, words.
Originally posted by
Sir
And honestly, why do people feel the need to use the terms "gay" or "retarded" in exchange for stupid or silly? Can they not just say the latter? I am at a loss of understanding here, regardless of the whole "words have the
...
more
And honestly, why do people feel the need to use the terms "gay" or "retarded" in exchange for stupid or silly? Can they not just say the latter? I am at a loss of understanding here, regardless of the whole "words have the meaning you give them."
I also do not feel that just because homosexuals use it is it any better, or an excuse. less
I also do not feel that just because homosexuals use it is it any better, or an excuse. less
Not saying you're wrong in your opinion, Sir, just that expecting people to not play with language is unrealistic. It's always happened, always will.
08/04/2010
I used to use the phrase pretty often without any after thoughts and I used it not as "That is retarded" but in a derogatory form such as one's appearance/behaviour/v oice/etc is gay. It was a common expression for me for when my partner and I went shopping for clothes for him (mostly) bcs he used it a lot to differentiate his style from a different style.
Since then I have changed how I see it. When I do use this phrase I feel guilty bcs I feel like I am using the word as a negative. I don't want to make a sexual orientation a negativism. Especially now, I have been reading about suicides of young boys in high schools who were being bullied for being gay/possibly gay. I had a friend in high school and his friends would always tease him about being gay/ what he did was gay, etc. I feel really guilty bcs it made it sort of personal for me and helped me see how words can be destructive.
I guess that as long as you go with how you feel its all good. I don't feel comfortable using this term (it's wrong for me but I can respect that others feel alright with using this term) but if someone else feels no guilt or negative emotions while using expressions such as "that is so gay" thats great.
I think you should respect yourself but at the same time respect others too.
Since then I have changed how I see it. When I do use this phrase I feel guilty bcs I feel like I am using the word as a negative. I don't want to make a sexual orientation a negativism. Especially now, I have been reading about suicides of young boys in high schools who were being bullied for being gay/possibly gay. I had a friend in high school and his friends would always tease him about being gay/ what he did was gay, etc. I feel really guilty bcs it made it sort of personal for me and helped me see how words can be destructive.
I guess that as long as you go with how you feel its all good. I don't feel comfortable using this term (it's wrong for me but I can respect that others feel alright with using this term) but if someone else feels no guilt or negative emotions while using expressions such as "that is so gay" thats great.
I think you should respect yourself but at the same time respect others too.
08/04/2010
Quote:
Yes, such things changes with the time period. However, I did read some back up to why people might think like this--we might be wired to think that blonds (or perhaps even other "unusual" hair colors like red?) are "weaker". :/
Originally posted by
El-Jaro
Before blondes, it used to be red-heads until...70's? Before my time, at least.
08/05/2010
I usually do say something, but I prefer a less confrontational method. Instead of telling them straight out that equating "gay" with "bad" is offensive, I just mock it: "Yes, Gabe, that movie was gay. It is sexually attracted to movies of the same gender."
08/05/2010
I sometimes get in trouble with gay friend for saying this around her. To it's two separate things.
08/05/2010
Quote:
I've done that as well. I had a friend who said that all the time and once when we were shopping she said a shirt was gay. SO I pulled it off the rack and made dancing motions..."gay " as in happy...and then said it was sitting next to the other shirt cause it was gonna get fresh! It's a silly slur but it has the power to hurt.
Originally posted by
joja
I usually do say something, but I prefer a less confrontational method. Instead of telling them straight out that equating "gay" with "bad" is offensive, I just mock it: "Yes, Gabe, that movie was gay. It is sexually
...
more
I usually do say something, but I prefer a less confrontational method. Instead of telling them straight out that equating "gay" with "bad" is offensive, I just mock it: "Yes, Gabe, that movie was gay. It is sexually attracted to movies of the same gender."
less
08/06/2010
I bitch them out in a diplomatic way and then correct them.
08/06/2010
I do tend to correct them - it happened the other day in Guild chat on Warcraft... I don't like hearing it - and that's personal choice, so I asked politely if he could try to refrain from using "gay" in a derogatory manner.
08/22/2010
It irks me whenever people say it, but I usually don't call them out on it. I feel like most of the time my saying something won't make a difference.
08/22/2010
Quote:
Actually, I have heard "that's so black" and "that's so Jewish before". I've heard people saying things are "Jewish" etc.
Originally posted by
Owl Identified
The difference between Scott Thompson saying "fag" and you, for example, using it is that he is gay and has had this word used against him before to demean him for who is he. He is entitled in every single way to use this word in order to
...
more
The difference between Scott Thompson saying "fag" and you, for example, using it is that he is gay and has had this word used against him before to demean him for who is he. He is entitled in every single way to use this word in order to reclaim it and cope with the hatred and/or violence he experienced/s. Straight people really need to think twice before they use this word, however, especially to denote something negative. In a world where straight people are granted privileges that gay people are not, is it really necessary to grasp one more "right" for yourself? The "right" to use a word that really causes appreciable harm to others? No one would say "oh my god, that's so black!" or "oh my god, that's so Jewish!"
It's also easier for you not to be offended by words because you haven't been systematically marginalized for your race, gender or sexual orientation. I was jumped and beat up in high school for being queer, and when I hear people say "that's so gay" I am really, really offended. It's nothing to do with being "PC," it's to do with being polite and considerate of the people around you. No one is saying you can't use a word, we're just asking that you don't because it's hurtful. My sincere question to you and other "free speech" crusaders is what's more important: your right to use every single word available to you, or my right to feel safe and valuable to this society and world that we inhabit. Because when people say "that's so gay" I do not feel safe nor do I feel valuable. I'm really tired of this "offended? that's YOUR problem" attitude. If someone is offended by your words then why shouldn't you be responsible for them and consider if they are really necessary? There is no law that says you can't say "that's so gay" and I would never strong arm someone into not saying it. All I can do is ask with sincerity that people consider the necessity of it because it hurts me, and with good reason. less
It's also easier for you not to be offended by words because you haven't been systematically marginalized for your race, gender or sexual orientation. I was jumped and beat up in high school for being queer, and when I hear people say "that's so gay" I am really, really offended. It's nothing to do with being "PC," it's to do with being polite and considerate of the people around you. No one is saying you can't use a word, we're just asking that you don't because it's hurtful. My sincere question to you and other "free speech" crusaders is what's more important: your right to use every single word available to you, or my right to feel safe and valuable to this society and world that we inhabit. Because when people say "that's so gay" I do not feel safe nor do I feel valuable. I'm really tired of this "offended? that's YOUR problem" attitude. If someone is offended by your words then why shouldn't you be responsible for them and consider if they are really necessary? There is no law that says you can't say "that's so gay" and I would never strong arm someone into not saying it. All I can do is ask with sincerity that people consider the necessity of it because it hurts me, and with good reason. less
Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to use it. Like African Americans and the n-word. Just cause they were called it, doesn't mean they should use it all the time. If they'd be offended by a white or any other race person saying it, why wouldn't they be from their own race? But that's a bit off subject.
As far as what I say. I'll call stuff gay, retarded, stupid, dumb, whatever word just happens to come out first. By saying gay or retarded, I don't mean offense to any one mentally handicapped or homosexual or anything. Retarded literally means slow, so saying something is retarded has NOTHING to do with someone with a mental disability. I think calling the person with the disability retarded is the insulting part. As far as gay, well it originally meant happy, so I don't have a reasoning for that one.
People are just way to sensitive anymore, especially with words. I mean wasn't everyone told the whole "Sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me" when they were little? Words only take the power you let them have. If you let someone offend you by saying something then you're letting them win.
08/22/2010
I honestly didn't find an option that I really "fit into" per say. Here's my theory on this. If I refer to something as "gay" I think of it as being happy. After all, that's the dictionary definition of "gay".
I don't like when people use "retarded" but, ya know, you can't control the masses. Honestly, people have tried for years and it doesn't work. I'm not going to beat someone over the head because they used a term that I don't necessarily like to hear.
If we really got into the logistics of it all, everything we say and refer to is offensive to someone along the line. It's kind of like telling someone "God, you're acting so blonde" in regard to doing or saying something stupid.
It happens. Life goes on. If yours doesn't because you're hung up on how someone phrased something then, well, that's your problem, not everyone else's.
I don't like when people use "retarded" but, ya know, you can't control the masses. Honestly, people have tried for years and it doesn't work. I'm not going to beat someone over the head because they used a term that I don't necessarily like to hear.
If we really got into the logistics of it all, everything we say and refer to is offensive to someone along the line. It's kind of like telling someone "God, you're acting so blonde" in regard to doing or saying something stupid.
It happens. Life goes on. If yours doesn't because you're hung up on how someone phrased something then, well, that's your problem, not everyone else's.
08/23/2010
I think what you say has nothing to do with it. If you really had a problem with gays I think that'd be a problem. Otherwise it's jsut a colloquialism.
08/25/2010
Quote:
So so Funny. In my early 20s I didnt know any openly homosexuals.. and I ALWAYS said "Im straight." not meaning anything to do with anything sexual. Well one day at work I said it while talking to an openly gay friend. and he replied.. "well, I already knew THAT!" which made me laugh but helped me realize that sometimes what we say is taken totally differently by different people. He and I are good friends now, and he frequently calls things gay ~LOL sometimes I have to use context queues to know whether he is talking about the slang term or if he is calling someone homosexual.
Originally posted by
~LaUr3n~
Let me explain me vote...I didn't like any of the other ones.
Ok so I don't say what you mean is that's retarded. But, I do make fun of it and say things like "Naw I'm straight". Or if someone asks me how I'm ... more
Ok so I don't say what you mean is that's retarded. But, I do make fun of it and say things like "Naw I'm straight". Or if someone asks me how I'm ... more
Let me explain me vote...I didn't like any of the other ones.
Ok so I don't say what you mean is that's retarded. But, I do make fun of it and say things like "Naw I'm straight". Or if someone asks me how I'm doing and I'm ok, I say "I'm bi". It's an inside joke. I think it is so funny that people have attached those words to things like that.
People who say that's gay aren't even using it as the real meaning, so let them look ignorant. less
Ok so I don't say what you mean is that's retarded. But, I do make fun of it and say things like "Naw I'm straight". Or if someone asks me how I'm doing and I'm ok, I say "I'm bi". It's an inside joke. I think it is so funny that people have attached those words to things like that.
People who say that's gay aren't even using it as the real meaning, so let them look ignorant. less
08/25/2010
here in WV that was said a lot. My friends and I do not said is unless the guy is homosexual and we are saying that he is gay. I have before got off at someone saying that in the wrong way. I was glad my man was there for me and understood why it does up set me. Now it is "that so Jewish" which I hate just as much
09/02/2010
Let me tell you, i've had to deal with this pretty much since 4th grade.
some backstory:
when i was 2 we moved to North Carolina, and since i was only two years old it really became where i "grew up". i'm very VERY much more southern than anyone else in my family. Before that nobody in my family had really left New England. mostly mass. so i'm kinda the outcast as it is. when i was 7 we packed up and moved back north, much to my chagrin. i hated it. New england was a cold, unfriendly wasteland of pretention and grouchy neighbors to a 7 year old southern boy. it was devistating. when i started at the local elementary school i still had a drawl and everything, and was once again the outcast. completely! i mean in grand total throughout all of elementary school i had 3 friends, one of whom would only act like my friend if her friends weren't around (lame, right?)
so i was made fun of for being new, being southern, being overweight. everything you can think of. Constantly called a girl or gay, even at that young age. the people in this town are messed up lol. i'm still here, and while nobody really makes fun of me anymore, it's still an issue.
throughout jr high and the first half of high school i was completely closeted. not because i was afraid of rejection (although i'm sure in my subconscious it was there) but because i didn't want to draw the attention to myself (i've since realized that my defense mechanism for dealing with New England grouches was to try and attract as little attention to myself as possible.) when my friends would say something i would correct them but gently (hey, that's not right, don't say that.) and as time progressed i let my friends off the hook, especially after coming out to them. we had an understanding that they meant it as a colloquialism and not an insult for being homosexual. however if and when i feel like someone i know is saying it without realizing what they're saying i still tell them to watch it, not in a threatening way. i don't understand why people think it's ok. would you say "that's so black"? or "that's so lesbian"? how about "that's so balinese"? where does it stop?
i it wouldn't be a big deal if people took the half a second to process the REAL MEANING of what they are saying. i don't think it would be a "thing" to say "that's so gay" if people actually thought of gay as meaning homosexual, instead of the mass-media driven definition of "bad" in some way.
it's not comfortable to hear, i guess unless you know it's not meant to hurt. but it hurts sometimes to this day no matter how many times you say you shrug it off.
some backstory:
when i was 2 we moved to North Carolina, and since i was only two years old it really became where i "grew up". i'm very VERY much more southern than anyone else in my family. Before that nobody in my family had really left New England. mostly mass. so i'm kinda the outcast as it is. when i was 7 we packed up and moved back north, much to my chagrin. i hated it. New england was a cold, unfriendly wasteland of pretention and grouchy neighbors to a 7 year old southern boy. it was devistating. when i started at the local elementary school i still had a drawl and everything, and was once again the outcast. completely! i mean in grand total throughout all of elementary school i had 3 friends, one of whom would only act like my friend if her friends weren't around (lame, right?)
so i was made fun of for being new, being southern, being overweight. everything you can think of. Constantly called a girl or gay, even at that young age. the people in this town are messed up lol. i'm still here, and while nobody really makes fun of me anymore, it's still an issue.
throughout jr high and the first half of high school i was completely closeted. not because i was afraid of rejection (although i'm sure in my subconscious it was there) but because i didn't want to draw the attention to myself (i've since realized that my defense mechanism for dealing with New England grouches was to try and attract as little attention to myself as possible.) when my friends would say something i would correct them but gently (hey, that's not right, don't say that.) and as time progressed i let my friends off the hook, especially after coming out to them. we had an understanding that they meant it as a colloquialism and not an insult for being homosexual. however if and when i feel like someone i know is saying it without realizing what they're saying i still tell them to watch it, not in a threatening way. i don't understand why people think it's ok. would you say "that's so black"? or "that's so lesbian"? how about "that's so balinese"? where does it stop?
i it wouldn't be a big deal if people took the half a second to process the REAL MEANING of what they are saying. i don't think it would be a "thing" to say "that's so gay" if people actually thought of gay as meaning homosexual, instead of the mass-media driven definition of "bad" in some way.
it's not comfortable to hear, i guess unless you know it's not meant to hurt. but it hurts sometimes to this day no matter how many times you say you shrug it off.
09/02/2010
Maybe what matters is why a word that once meant happy, but these days almost universally means homosexual, suddenly turned into a word that means stupid ugly and wrong.
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it as a slur, it still is, because the word gay is being used to mean stupid ugly and wrong. And that's a slur. Until the day being stupid, ugly and wrong is something to aspire to. A day that's not so far away, I suspect.
Couldn't we just substitute the phrases 'Goldman-Sachs', or 'Palinesque'instead? Or even 'Popish'? Those couldn't cause any offence, surely?
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it as a slur, it still is, because the word gay is being used to mean stupid ugly and wrong. And that's a slur. Until the day being stupid, ugly and wrong is something to aspire to. A day that's not so far away, I suspect.
Couldn't we just substitute the phrases 'Goldman-Sachs', or 'Palinesque'instead? Or even 'Popish'? Those couldn't cause any offence, surely?
09/14/2010
Quote:
I think it's definitely a slur - and intended to be. No one says it to be nice. But I think often they don't mean it as a slur against those who are homosexual but rather just a general insult.
Originally posted by
Bill Ditchburn
Maybe what matters is why a word that once meant happy, but these days almost universally means homosexual, suddenly turned into a word that means stupid ugly and wrong.
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it ... more
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it ... more
Maybe what matters is why a word that once meant happy, but these days almost universally means homosexual, suddenly turned into a word that means stupid ugly and wrong.
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it as a slur, it still is, because the word gay is being used to mean stupid ugly and wrong. And that's a slur. Until the day being stupid, ugly and wrong is something to aspire to. A day that's not so far away, I suspect.
Couldn't we just substitute the phrases 'Goldman-Sachs', or 'Palinesque'instead? Or even 'Popish'? Those couldn't cause any offence, surely? less
And no matter how often people who use it say they don't intend it as a slur, it still is, because the word gay is being used to mean stupid ugly and wrong. And that's a slur. Until the day being stupid, ugly and wrong is something to aspire to. A day that's not so far away, I suspect.
Couldn't we just substitute the phrases 'Goldman-Sachs', or 'Palinesque'instead? Or even 'Popish'? Those couldn't cause any offence, surely? less
It kind of reminds me of the use of sarcasm. You hear people, all the time, saying "What? I was just kidding, just being sarcastic!" and most of them don't realize that sarcasm is, indeed, a form of humor but it's a mean form of humor, meant to convey insult.
09/15/2010
I had a discussion about this in lecture the other day. Many groups of people take back the term that were used against them negatively to turn into something positive. For example, women were called bitches, which was a negative. Now there are women who refer themselves as bitches.
09/16/2010
I take it as a sign that someone can't express themselves properly/intelligently .
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use.
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use.
09/18/2010
Quote:
So on point and I couldn't agree more with you.
Originally posted by
clp
I take it as a sign that someone can't express themselves properly/intelligently .
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts ... more
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts ... more
I take it as a sign that someone can't express themselves properly/intelligently .
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use. less
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use. less
09/18/2010
Quote:
HAHA! I like that response, that was funny.
Originally posted by
clp
I take it as a sign that someone can't express themselves properly/intelligently .
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts ... more
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts ... more
I take it as a sign that someone can't express themselves properly/intelligently .
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use. less
As smart as someone may give the impression of being, you take it all back when you say thoughtless phrases like that. I immediately seek company that puts effort and consideration in the words they use. less
I generally do feel the same way, actually. I think of the person as lower than me when they start using such terms in those ways.
10/09/2010
Quote:
I understand to some extent. Our family has a lot of GLBT friends, so I also try to let my kids know it isn't really nice. Once they reach a certain age, they make up their own minds as to what is appropriate to say, depending on their peer group, the people they are with etc.
Originally posted by
Carrie Ann
Words, for the most part, only have the power you give them.
I grew up on the 80's. "That's so gay!" was standard vocabulary. Not a single one of us, at 12 years old, thought about gay people when we said it.
Just ... more
I grew up on the 80's. "That's so gay!" was standard vocabulary. Not a single one of us, at 12 years old, thought about gay people when we said it.
Just ... more
Words, for the most part, only have the power you give them.
I grew up on the 80's. "That's so gay!" was standard vocabulary. Not a single one of us, at 12 years old, thought about gay people when we said it.
Just like kids don't think of sick people when they say their friend's new ipod is "totally sick, man!"
Just like, being Polish, I don't get my panties in a wad over Polish jokes or, when I was blonde, didn't get mad at blonde jokes. I don't get upset when people talk about BDSM or kink as being deviant.
Words just don't have that much power, to me, unless they're intentionally hurtful. Intent is everything.
I do teach my son to be careful with how he speaks, to not say things that may be hurtful to others, to not run around the mall cussing and acting a fool. But, hell, half the words teenagers use today don't even make sense to me. None of them mean what they actually mean - and I look at "gay" in that context the same way.
I'm not 12 anymore. I rarely say it anymore - though I'll admit that each generation DOES hold on to the words of it's youth.
Just last week a friend of mines mom was telling me how... totally hip she is and how her husband was such a square. I'm guessing she didn't mean the hip bone or the four sided shape... less
I grew up on the 80's. "That's so gay!" was standard vocabulary. Not a single one of us, at 12 years old, thought about gay people when we said it.
Just like kids don't think of sick people when they say their friend's new ipod is "totally sick, man!"
Just like, being Polish, I don't get my panties in a wad over Polish jokes or, when I was blonde, didn't get mad at blonde jokes. I don't get upset when people talk about BDSM or kink as being deviant.
Words just don't have that much power, to me, unless they're intentionally hurtful. Intent is everything.
I do teach my son to be careful with how he speaks, to not say things that may be hurtful to others, to not run around the mall cussing and acting a fool. But, hell, half the words teenagers use today don't even make sense to me. None of them mean what they actually mean - and I look at "gay" in that context the same way.
I'm not 12 anymore. I rarely say it anymore - though I'll admit that each generation DOES hold on to the words of it's youth.
Just last week a friend of mines mom was telling me how... totally hip she is and how her husband was such a square. I'm guessing she didn't mean the hip bone or the four sided shape... less
That being said, I am working on becoming a less "offended" person. (Per what Second Wave Feminism did to me. EVERYTHING "offended" me from the age of 12 until just the last few years.) I'm trying to lighten up. I think in a lot of situations we can choose whether or not to become offended. In other situations, where someone really intends HATE in their language and their meaning, it's a different story.
But, I still want my children to know that words can hurt some people. My kids knew what "Gay" meant since they were toddlers. So, if someone called one of my kids "Gay" or "Ghey" or whatever, they would sometimes correct them. "No, I'm not gay. Gay is when you fall in love with someone of the same gender." I got in trouble with a few other parents for that. They had NO problem with their kids (I'm talking kids under 10) using the word "Gay" but didn't want their kids to know what it meant. WTF? "Why are you telling my kids things I don't want them to know about yet?" I was asked by more than one parent. My question for them is, "Why is your kid using a word he doesn't know the meaning of? And, why don't your kids know the actual meaning of the word "gay?""
It's amazing what passes for "OK" in some people's homes. According to some of these parents, an 8 year old calling an other kid "Gay" is fine, an other 8 year old actually explaining what the word means is "wrong."
*sigh*
10/14/2010
Quote:
lucid, you asked Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to use it. Like African Americans and the n-word. Just cause they were called it, doesn't mean they should use it all the time. If they'd be offended by a white or any other race person saying it, why wouldn't they be from their own race?
Originally posted by
sextoygeek
Actually, I have heard "that's so black" and "that's so Jewish before". I've heard people saying things are "Jewish" etc.
Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to ... more
Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to ... more
Actually, I have heard "that's so black" and "that's so Jewish before". I've heard people saying things are "Jewish" etc.
Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to use it. Like African Americans and the n-word. Just cause they were called it, doesn't mean they should use it all the time. If they'd be offended by a white or any other race person saying it, why wouldn't they be from their own race? But that's a bit off subject.
As far as what I say. I'll call stuff gay, retarded, stupid, dumb, whatever word just happens to come out first. By saying gay or retarded, I don't mean offense to any one mentally handicapped or homosexual or anything. Retarded literally means slow, so saying something is retarded has NOTHING to do with someone with a mental disability. I think calling the person with the disability retarded is the insulting part. As far as gay, well it originally meant happy, so I don't have a reasoning for that one.
People are just way to sensitive anymore, especially with words. I mean wasn't everyone told the whole "Sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me" when they were little? Words only take the power you let them have. If you let someone offend you by saying something then you're letting them win. less
Also, having a word used against you doesn't give you more of a right to use it. Like African Americans and the n-word. Just cause they were called it, doesn't mean they should use it all the time. If they'd be offended by a white or any other race person saying it, why wouldn't they be from their own race? But that's a bit off subject.
As far as what I say. I'll call stuff gay, retarded, stupid, dumb, whatever word just happens to come out first. By saying gay or retarded, I don't mean offense to any one mentally handicapped or homosexual or anything. Retarded literally means slow, so saying something is retarded has NOTHING to do with someone with a mental disability. I think calling the person with the disability retarded is the insulting part. As far as gay, well it originally meant happy, so I don't have a reasoning for that one.
People are just way to sensitive anymore, especially with words. I mean wasn't everyone told the whole "Sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me" when they were little? Words only take the power you let them have. If you let someone offend you by saying something then you're letting them win. less
No, it's really different. When the Dominant-Oppressor Group uses a word that THEY invented to be derogatory, it is often up to the Oppressed Group to TAKE BACK, reclaim that word for their own usage. It is STILL not "OK" for members of the Dominant-Oppressor Group, who still has much power over the Oppressed to say, "How come I can't say it?" The Dominant-Oppressor Group has had their say, their power is waning, but still somewhat intact and once the word becomes verboten, (like the N word) it is ONLY up to the Oppressed, for whom the word was used at one time ONLY BY the Oppressors, to use the word to their liking.
Case in point, it is up to women to "reclaim" words like "Bitch" and "Whore" and "Slut." Only when the word is wrung of it's power over us, is it then safe for general usage. (And that ain't happened yet for general usage for the "N" word.)
Seeing how African Americans were treated by the Dominant-Oppressor Group (white people, crackers, what ever you want to call it) it is going to be a LONG fucking time before white people should at all consider it "OK to say, because they do it!" As a Caucasian, one hasn't been through the Oppression, so giving up ONE word out of your vocabulary isn't a huge deal. It also isn't up to white people to TELL Black people when, where or how often THEY can use words deemed inappropriate. We've done that. That's over. (Sorta, not really all the way.) The usage of the word now belongs to the Group who was once Oppressed in part, by these words.
Words DO have power, and often the Dominant-Oppressor Groups gave them this power, the Oppressed didn't! Black slaves didn't "let Massa win" by getting offended by being called the "N" word. The Oppressors did that to them. "Massa" was winning at one point DUE to in part, the use of his language. You can't blame the victim. And IMO, and the opinion of many, only those effected by the ill usage of these words can be the ones to strip these words of their power.
Likewise, It isn't up to men to try to "reclaim" the word "Bitch" (in relation to a woman) nor is is up to Straight people to try to "reclaim" words like "Fag" or "Homo." In some situations it may be accepted but if you have to think about it or ask, it probably isn't OK. People who know each other well may have no problem with some words being used. If My Man is joking around and calls me "Bitch" is is totally different than some random guy on the street. Why? Because, as member of the once Oppressed, I've given My Man permission. (This could be oral or implied permission.) Same goes for some friends and relatives of GLBT people and some white friends of African American people. BUT, in the end, the Oppressed really, at this point in time, should be the one to control the use of the word. But, like I said, if you think you have to ask, or even think "Is this OK?" it probably isn't.
Spike Lee could have said it much better.....
(And I still need to work on this "not becoming offended" thing. I'm much better, than I was really. This discussion doesn't "offend" me at all, but I just felt I needed to say something about the whole "How come those people can say this word and I can't?" thing.) But, only by bringing things out in the open can we learn. I truly believe that. And, it's one of the things I LOVE about Eden. We can talk about this stuff without fear or abuse, like rational adults.
I thank you all for that.
As always, mileage and all that. There are a LOT of other trains of thought on this than the one I expressed, so I guess go with your gut. I just had to say something about the whole "N" word thing.
10/14/2010
To turn it inside-out and deflate: Can anyone ever say "That's so straight"?
Unless what they're talking about is literally straight, I don't think so.
Unless what they're talking about is literally straight, I don't think so.
10/14/2010
Quote:
In most circles, "Straight" has never had unpleasant or slur connotations, so no.
Originally posted by
El-Jaro
To turn it inside-out and deflate: Can anyone ever say "That's so straight"?
Unless what they're talking about is literally straight, I don't think so.
Unless what they're talking about is literally straight, I don't think so.
On an other note, a few hundred years ago, the word "Silly" meant mentally retarded. Now, we use it all the time, without thinking about it. But, it's really only been since the the Holocaust and the Civil Rights Movement that people have really thought about the impact of language on how others are treated.
10/14/2010
Quote:
It kind of offends me when people say it.
Originally posted by
Timaree
How do you respond? Do you say anything, like "that's offensive," or "i think you mean, 'that sucks.'" Or do you let it go and think to yourself?
10/15/2010
I call people on -ist word choices, but privately and respectfully. I've heard the "intent doesn't matter, if it could hurt someone the speaker needs to suffer!" argument, but intent matters to the speaker, and you're more likely to have success convincing people to think about their word choices if you don't put them on the defensive. Context also matters, as does choosing one's battles. I'm not throwing myself on my sword to bicker with the more homophobic and judgmental people in my life on topics of grammar, when I know that if I wait fifteen minutes, I could probably argue with them on the topic of gay marriage instead.
And sometimes "that's so gay" is a perfectly valid statement, although among my friends it's more like to be "that's so slashy" in reference to a panel in a comic book or a scene on a television show.
And sometimes "that's so gay" is a perfectly valid statement, although among my friends it's more like to be "that's so slashy" in reference to a panel in a comic book or a scene on a television show.
10/15/2010
Honestly it irritates me... Im not even 100% sure why.
10/30/2010