Jelly and rubber. I hate Jelly because it is so unsafe and rubber just feels cheap and smells. and is unsafe... yea it's awful.

I picked jelly because of the overwhelming stench it carries. That chemical smell and the porosity factor just turn me off of the material completely. I had three Jelly/PVC toys in the past, and I will never go back to that.

Jelly. My body really doesn't like it. My first dildo was jelly, and it made me burn...

Jelly.

Never had the experience or being a part of using jelly toys, but I have to say that after hearing all the negative opinion's about jelly, that's what I voted for.

No wood for me

I hate that jelly deteriorates, then smells, and gets gross looking.

Jelly is suuuuch a gross sex toy material. Not only does it smell horrible, but it causes mild chemical burns in my vagina. I've retired my one jelly toy forever.

I definitely dont like rubber smell, especially burnt.

not a big jelly fan

Jelly. Yuck.

I really don't like the sil a gel, It smells terrible!

Jelly or Jel-Lee

Jelly.

I don't have a big problem with jelly because I can just cover jelly toys, but I'd never buy a jelly cock ring. I DON'T like hard plastic for vibrators/dildos, it's so stiff and uncomfortable. I MUCH prefer soft materials for penetrating toys. I guess plastic is alright for bullets and eggs, but I'd rather they were coated in silicone or something softer anyways.

Jelly, it's awful stuff. Almost impossible to clean and doesn't feel all that great either.

Definitely jelly. It baffles me that they continue to sell such an unpredictable and unsafe material. I tend to stay away from anything under a 6 or 7 on the safety rating scale.

Jelly seems to be the clear "winner" here.

There's a few good "bad" choices, but I say jelly, because it's SO pretty and enticing, and yet so unsafe. When I was uneducated, I was attracted to a pretty clear/blue jelly toy and didn't know how bad it was, and spent over 60 bucks on it. I ended up learning more, and ended up tossing it.

I can't stand rubber. The smell is awful and putting it inside me is out of the question. I don't really like "regular" silicone either; I like realism and it's much harder than the real thing.

I like cyberskin and UR3, but only for oral. They're so realistic it's easy to pretend they're the real thing. That realism makes it easier to put up with the difficulty of cleaning and storing them. One thing I actually like (but others might hate) about cyberskin is that you can bend them for a day or so and they'll hold the new shape for a while. I've added a nice curve to a couple of mine.

Vixskin is awesome for penetration. Anally, Vixskin feels real. Orally, not as much. (I'm a guy and my wife doesn't like being penetrated with dildos, so I don't know about vaginally). Cleanup is easy and I've never had a problem storing them or any noticeable wear, even after years of use. Vamp Silicone's Softskin and Tantus's O2 are also pretty good (same easy cleanup and durability), but Vixskin is the best so far.

Glass is also good for anal. I have two glass plugs which are perfect for "warm-up". Again, effortless cleanup.

Jelly is bad and icky!!!!

Jelly. Mostly for the safety concerns. And of course the way that so many jelly toys reek.

jelly, with latex a close second

wood is gross

Jelly! But I also steer clear of latex for sensitivity issues.

I dislike rubber and jelly