I voted yes, because one can be amazing and the other utter shit. I once bought lube, and the strawberry champagne taste was amazing, but the chocolate one was very, very meh and tasted like chemicals or something.
Would you write two reviews for the same product but in different scents?
04/02/2012
Definitely put them in the same review or in a follow up! I think it would be really useful to hear about the different scents.
04/15/2012
I don't think the system would let you but I could be wrong.
08/06/2012
Personally I'd just mention it in the follow up.
08/07/2012
Quote:
Yes, because they're different enough
Originally posted by
Ryuson
I'm just finishing up two reviews for two of the Venus body products, one that I'm thrilled with and one that I'm on the fence about. Because I want to see if there is a difference between the spray scent and the lotion scent in a
...
more
I'm just finishing up two reviews for two of the Venus body products, one that I'm thrilled with and one that I'm on the fence about. Because I want to see if there is a difference between the spray scent and the lotion scent in a different overall smell I was considering doing a buyout on the Cucumber melon products...
But if I do this I'd have two reviews for the same product, but in different scents! Would you do this if you were me? Or would you buy them full price and maybe mention it in the follow up review?
Thank you so much for your help! less
But if I do this I'd have two reviews for the same product, but in different scents! Would you do this if you were me? Or would you buy them full price and maybe mention it in the follow up review?
Thank you so much for your help! less
08/07/2012
If you had different reactions from the two scents, i.e. one was great, one wasn't so great, definitely two reviews. I've thought about this because we have a body butter in two scents.
08/08/2012
Quote:
Yes, because they're different enough
Originally posted by
Ryuson
I'm just finishing up two reviews for two of the Venus body products, one that I'm thrilled with and one that I'm on the fence about. Because I want to see if there is a difference between the spray scent and the lotion scent in a
...
more
I'm just finishing up two reviews for two of the Venus body products, one that I'm thrilled with and one that I'm on the fence about. Because I want to see if there is a difference between the spray scent and the lotion scent in a different overall smell I was considering doing a buyout on the Cucumber melon products...
But if I do this I'd have two reviews for the same product, but in different scents! Would you do this if you were me? Or would you buy them full price and maybe mention it in the follow up review?
Thank you so much for your help! less
But if I do this I'd have two reviews for the same product, but in different scents! Would you do this if you were me? Or would you buy them full price and maybe mention it in the follow up review?
Thank you so much for your help! less
08/09/2012
Total posts: 37
Unique posters: 34
- 1
-
2