Do you prefer reading standard or extended review formats?

Contributor: Nora Nora
I find that the standard format leaves me looking for information that has been completely left out of the reviews. With the Extended format, it gives the writer "Oh, yeah, I need to write about that" cues.

Also, the "minimum" character lengths in the extended format result in reviews that are longer than three to four short sentences. I have seen far too many standard format reviews that all look about the same...

"I liked it. It was tight and didn't stretch much, use lube." They are slightly longer, but that is the gist of them. If something is supposed to stretch and doesn't do it "much", I want to know how much it actually stretched! If it smells "funny", what does it remind you of? Anywho, preaching to the choir at this point...
08/27/2011
Contributor: VanillaFreeSex VanillaFreeSex
It depends on the product. When I decide which format to use I base my decision on how much to I have to say about the product. I also consider if the categories in the extended review format would make sense or not for the product review.

When it comes to reading reviews it doesn't matter to me.
08/28/2011
Contributor: bluekaren bluekaren
Quote:
Originally posted by VanillaFreeSex
It depends on the product. When I decide which format to use I base my decision on how much to I have to say about the product. I also consider if the categories in the extended review format would make sense or not for the product ... more
I agree with Storm in that it definitely depends on what I am reviewing. A book or cleaner may not work so well with the extended format. Also, I like to combine my thoughts in a standard format. I am talking about the texture, which leads me to talk about how to clean it, which leads me to how to store it and the packaging.

I don't care what format is used for reviews as long as all the basics are covered. I hate when people use the standard format and forget major points, like cleaning and dimensions. I go back threw my reviews, sometimes over a few days before publishing, to make sure I try to cover all the points. Some of this has come with experience and I am glad the extended format was there for me in the beginning to remind me what I needed to include in my reviews. That is not to say that the extended format is only for beginners...I use it too sometimes but I like the freedom of standard more.
08/28/2011
Contributor: Beck Beck
Extended for me, it is easier! I hate that some items only have standard.
08/31/2011
Contributor: Apirka Apirka
I like extended better. It breaks everything up into little sections.
03/25/2012