Should the bridesmaid voice her opinion of her dress or keep her freaking mouth shut?

Contributor: Sinfully Sinfully
I would say how I feel but wouldnt bitch about it.
12/05/2011
Contributor: Ms. Spice Ms. Spice
if someone told me that they didn't like the dress I put them in, I'll probably either get sad or kind of pissed. More than likely the Bride is paying for the dress, so I personally would keep my mouth shut unless it didn't fit properly.
12/05/2011
Contributor: Kdlove Kdlove
I think so
12/05/2011
Contributor: hpnotiqserenity hpnotiqserenity
I agree with Pgell, the wedding day is not the most important part of being married! I do think that it is the bride's day, but she should also to a point take into consideration her bridesmaids opinions about the dresses. The bridesmaids should not be ruling the wedding though!
12/06/2011
Contributor: cheetahpita cheetahpita
Quote:
Originally posted by Maiden
Ultimately I have to agree that it is the bride's day and they should just suck it up. There are two instances where I feel they should voice their opinion. One: the dress doesn't look well on their body type. I know as a plus sized woman, I ... more
Second this. It is the Bride's wedding, and the bridesmaids need to understand that and realize they might not be wearing a color or style that they like. But when it comes to something that is unflattering to the point of indecent, a bridesmaid should speak up. I have a friend who is getting married next year and picked out gorgeous strapless sweetheart neckline gowns for her bridesmaids... without thinking about how two of them are quite large in the chest area and would not be able to wear the dress without showing lots of cleavage. Thankfully it was easily remedied by adding straps, but in that case it was good that the bridesmaids spoke up before the day of the wedding!
12/06/2011
Contributor: Chirple Chirple
I don't understand why weddings have become theatre shows.

You used to just wear your nicest clothes, no matchy-matchy and forcing everyone to buy new clothes and look the same.

While I don't think it's completely wrong, and if that's what you want and everyone can really afford it - go for it, I think more people should evaluate the idea of a wedding and think outside the box.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Redboxbaby Redboxbaby
My bridesmaids had only one requirement . They had to wear a black dress (we had an evening wedding)of their choosing; preferably one they already owned. They all were unique and stunning.

I think it is ridiculous the amounts of money that are wasted on dresses that will never see the light of day again. Maybe I am too practical.
12/06/2011
Contributor: SaMiKaY SaMiKaY
I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH YOU!

I, too, watch those shows (and am completely addicted!) and when some of those bridesmaids get to going, I honestly wanna reach though the screen and slap them! If I were a bridesmaid, I would start off by asking the bride to pick something that would work with my body type and let her chose what she wanted, because she IS the bride...
12/06/2011
Contributor: TheSlyFox TheSlyFox
I'm about to get married-I let My bridesmaids pick out their dresses, but they had to stick to the color scheme and I had to like it, she found one she loved, and luckily i loved it too, but i made the final say since i was the one paying for her dress anyways.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Errant Venture Errant Venture
Granted, I wouldn't be in such a position, but I've never been one to keep quiet about something that irks me. If a guy I know wanted me as a best man and wanted me to wear some florid suit, I'd definitely speak up. Furthermore, if I were to inflict something like that on my best friend, I'd expect him to speak up (otherwise I wouldn't think much of him, and thus not best man material), and if he has a point, I'd change it to something we both can agree on.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Errant Venture Errant Venture
Quote:
Originally posted by TheSlyFox
I'm about to get married-I let My bridesmaids pick out their dresses, but they had to stick to the color scheme and I had to like it, she found one she loved, and luckily i loved it too, but i made the final say since i was the one paying for her ... more
Yeah, like that. It makes no sense to me that there has to be so much friction.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Shellz31 Shellz31
I think it's ok if they voice their opinion, but they either need to accept that's what the bride wants or ditch the job altogether.

I'd take the second option personally. I think being a bridesmaid is the worst job EVER and I'll NEVER do it again!
12/06/2011
Contributor: P'Gell P'Gell
Quote:
Originally posted by Redboxbaby
My bridesmaids had only one requirement . They had to wear a black dress (we had an evening wedding)of their choosing; preferably one they already owned. They all were unique and stunning.

I think it is ridiculous the amounts of money that ... more
Good idea. I bet it was beautiful and unique.

I, too, think that people are too impracticable about weddings.

I've only stood up to one wedding, my mom's second wedding. The dress was, of course hideous. I was standing up with my step sister, who was a cutter, so the dresses had turtle necks and long sleeves. I hate turtle necks and long sleeves and I looked hideous in the dress.

Most of my friends' parents couldn't afford big weddings and/or they only had a Maid of Honor (usually their sister, my step sister was a lesbian, so of course no wedding years ago) so I have never had the "honor" (thank G*d) to have to stand up in a wedding. My friends now are too old to have "Wedding parties" with people standing up, (I would certainly hope a woman my age wouldn't go insane like a 23 year old girl and have a Bridezilla type wedding) so there's no fear it will ever happen.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Jul!a Jul!a
Quote:
Originally posted by GravyCakes
i love watching say yes to the dress & all those shows that deal w/ wedding dress & bridesmaids dress sales. whenever i watch a bridal party pick out bridesmaids dresses, though, it's the same every time. the bride wants a certain look ... more
I actually saw that episode!


In my opinion, you do what the bride wants. Sometimes that can seem to bite you in the ass when the bride wants something you think is super tacky, but if you're there to support your friend you support your friend and suck it up and wear the dress you don't like. I've seen people get into huge fights over bridesmaids dresses, and I've been saddled with dresses that I can't wear again and had to pay a decent amount of money for. This is why I opted for something that really could be worn again and made sure to get my bridesmaids opinions on it. I mostly had a specific color in mind, and found a dress that everybody was happy with.
12/06/2011
Contributor: Adriana Ravenlust Adriana Ravenlust
Quote:
Originally posted by Ms. Spice
if someone told me that they didn't like the dress I put them in, I'll probably either get sad or kind of pissed. More than likely the Bride is paying for the dress, so I personally would keep my mouth shut unless it didn't fit properly.
I disagree that it's likely the bride is paying for the dress. A lot of bridesmaids have to pay for their own. This could be a location thing but all the weddings I've been in required the bridesmaids to buy their own dresses.

I think bridesmaids should be given a reasonable voice considering they're frequently throwing money out the window. I mean, who really gets more than one use out of the dress? Not many. Maybe they don't need to love the dress but if it something they truly hate, how much fun are they going to have at a wedding..? IE, how are they going to contribute to the bride's day?

But what bride really wants her bridesmaids to look poor or feel uncomfortable? That's probably a bigger issue in itself (the bride's a bitch).
12/07/2011