I've heard so much bad stuff that I have absolutely no interest in reading them.
Have you read Fifty Shades? Do you want to?
07/18/2012
I started reading them but stopped.
07/18/2012
I plan to read them, but have been waiting until I finish a series I am working on. Such mixed reviews though.
07/18/2012
Quote:
Thank you for that detailed description
Originally posted by
charletnarouh
I read all three books, only for the sake of being able to critique and review them thoroughly and fairly. They are poorly written with an unlikely plot full of holes, fraught with crutches for weak writing, redundancy, ignorantly used lofty
...
more
I read all three books, only for the sake of being able to critique and review them thoroughly and fairly. They are poorly written with an unlikely plot full of holes, fraught with crutches for weak writing, redundancy, ignorantly used lofty synonyms, cliches, inconsistencies, and a veritable myriad of other problems. For those who don't know, the story was originally published as a serialized fan fiction project based on Stephanie Meyer's Twilight series. It seems it gained enough popularity to be changed just enough to render it able to stand alone for publication in its own right. The characters are weak, flat, static and inconsistant. Those looking for a story about BDSM will be disappointed. This series paints BDSM and practitioners thereof as damaged, unhealthy people needing to be saved from their darkness by true love. BDSM and D/s relationships are portrayed as the very antithesis of a loving, healthy relationship. The author also propagates the popular myth of "natural" submissives and the idea that those who are not "natural submissives" will never be capable of happily submitting or serving. The love story that evolves is controlling and borderline abusive, but largely vanilla with a sparse peppering light bondage and other play, which the characters call "kinky fuckery", just one of the many grossly overused phrases throughout the books. The author has done both the literary world and the kink/fetish/leather/BD SM community a huge disservice. The unfathomable popularity of this series has not only set the effort to promote acceptance and understanding of BDSM back but will likely spawn a new "generation" of newcomers to kink who will have a warped misconception of the lifestyle.
less
...saved me the effort of reading the book and being disappointed
07/18/2012
Quote:
No, I wouldn't say she was forced into the contract. Manipulated maybe. Basically, he just said that if she didn't sign, he wouldn't have any kind of relationship with her. Which still leaves her with a choice. They discussed and negotiated at length. But it didn't remain in effect very long. So moot point as you said.
Originally posted by
- Kira -
I thought I had heard in more than a few places that she was forced into the contract, not that it was really ever consensually discussed. Though I guess if it never comes back up it's really neither here nor there and thus pointless.
My ... more
My ... more
I thought I had heard in more than a few places that she was forced into the contract, not that it was really ever consensually discussed. Though I guess if it never comes back up it's really neither here nor there and thus pointless.
My guess is that she had a fantasy about the harder stuff but didn't know enough about it to write anything on those subjects. Since research and/or writing skills seem to be lacking, no hard stuff.
The really sad thing is that I bet with a good writer and some knowledge of the lifestyle, the book could have been not only a good read, but good for the community as a whole. Instead it just furthers misconceptions, as best I can tell. less
My guess is that she had a fantasy about the harder stuff but didn't know enough about it to write anything on those subjects. Since research and/or writing skills seem to be lacking, no hard stuff.
The really sad thing is that I bet with a good writer and some knowledge of the lifestyle, the book could have been not only a good read, but good for the community as a whole. Instead it just furthers misconceptions, as best I can tell. less
07/18/2012
Total posts: 35
Unique posters: 30
- 1
-
2