The New Intimacy

Which pie is your favorite for Thanksgiving?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: shielaray shielaray
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
I like homemade fruit pies with fresh fruit and honey!
11/10/2012
Contributor: travelnurse travelnurse
Oh that pecan dark chocolate sounds awesome!!!! We usually have pumpkin.
11/11/2012
Contributor: MissCandyland MissCandyland
I love cherry pie, peach cobbler, and blackberry cobbler.
11/11/2012
Contributor: Sweet-n-Playful Sweet-n-Playful
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
Definitely Sweet Potato Pie!
11/11/2012
Contributor: Martiniman Martiniman
Pumpkin, followed closely by pecan.
11/11/2012
Contributor: butts butts
I love ALL kinds of pies 8D I really love pie! I think Cherry is my least favorite though, I've never had a cherry pie that I went nuts for. I really only like cherries fresh.
11/11/2012
Contributor: woodsdragon woodsdragon
Dessert in general lol
11/11/2012
Contributor: Lioncub Lioncub
Pumpkin followed by a chocolate pie with cool whip.
11/11/2012
Contributor: Lildrummrgurl7 Lildrummrgurl7
Pumpkin and eggnog! Everyone always forgets about eggnog pie.
11/11/2012
Contributor: yw2 yw2
We have pumpkin or sweet potato pie. Or red velvet cake, yum.
11/11/2012
Contributor: dawnkye dawnkye
Pumpkin! But pecan is a close second. And one swipe of someone else's chocolate pie is the best. And now I desperately want pie.
11/11/2012
Contributor: Supervixen Supervixen
Quote:
Originally posted by Lildrummrgurl7
Pumpkin and eggnog! Everyone always forgets about eggnog pie.
I've never heard of eggnog pie! But I love eggnog. I'm intrigued.
11/11/2012
Contributor: Supervixen Supervixen
Quote:
Originally posted by Sweet-n-Playful
Definitely Sweet Potato Pie!
I knew I was forgetting another favorite!
11/11/2012
Contributor: Supervixen Supervixen
Growing up, lemon meringue was my favorite, followed by key lime. I want to make something the family will all love. My dad seems to be a berry pie person (and coconut cream, which mom always makes), and my mom loves apple and pecan. I feel like I'm going to have to make five pies to cover everyone's tastes.

But then again, there's nothing wrong with more pie.
11/11/2012
Contributor: shorejen9 shorejen9
Pumpkin, blueberry, cherry, Apple, strawberry-rhubarb, and lemon meringue in that order for thanksgiving.
11/11/2012
Contributor: britanny0620 britanny0620
I only recently started liking pumpkin pie, but I also love apple pie
11/11/2012
Contributor: KrissyNovacaine KrissyNovacaine
Pumpkin!
11/11/2012
Contributor: AHubbyof2SexualMinds AHubbyof2SexualMinds
I love apple pie. I would have said cherry pie since it's my favorite, but we never have it at Thanksgiving. But honestly, most of the time I'm so full from the meal that I don't eat pie until later on that night!
11/12/2012
Contributor: TheirPet TheirPet
Pumpkin, though I love banana creme and pear-blueberry pies.
11/12/2012
Contributor: padmeamidala padmeamidala
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
Pumpkin
11/12/2012
Contributor: XxFallenAngelxX XxFallenAngelxX
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
Pumpkin!
11/12/2012
Contributor: tequilafish tequilafish
I seriously love pie, it's hands down the best dessert. My brother makes a killer key-lime and my mom is the master of blueberry. Last year we had five different kinds, I think. I bet we'll have about the same this year. It's the one time a year that I say "Yes, I'm going to eat five pieces of pie in one day, and it's gonna be awesome." I'm not a big fan of turkey, so pie is the entire point of the holiday for me (well, that and family!).
11/13/2012
Contributor: wicked weasel wicked weasel
Banana cream pie!
11/13/2012
Contributor: neil i. neil i.
I like a variety, but if it came down to only one, it'd have to be pumpkin, hands down.
11/13/2012
Contributor: Virgingasms Virgingasms
Cherry and lemon meringue are my absolute favorites, but we never seem to have lemon at Thanksgiving.
11/14/2012
Contributor: Ashleyxx Ashleyxx
Cake lover here
11/15/2012
Contributor: damnbul12 damnbul12
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
Cherry
11/15/2012
Contributor: Bignuf Bignuf
Quote:
Originally posted by Supervixen
Me, my sister and my mum will all probably make a couple of pies (seriously, you can never have too many pies at Thanksgiving. Even if we run out of fridge space, we just use that as an excuse to eat the pie "before it goes bad." ) I'm ... more
Chocolate cake...but if it's pie, a good Cherry is hard to beat (but hard to find).
01/28/2013
Contributor: ththpup ththpup
I'd vote pumpkin any time of year.
01/28/2013