Quote:
Originally posted by
Anthony C
I'm trying to understand...I saw a post that said, psychologically speaking, some identify themselves as the opposite sex therefore…they are...or identify themselves as so.
I know, I’m more literal then many, but I was under the impression
...
more
I'm trying to understand...I saw a post that said, psychologically speaking, some identify themselves as the opposite sex therefore…they are...or identify themselves as so.
I know, I’m more literal then many, but I was under the impression that genitals, organs, hormones, skeletal structure, reproductive systems etc., it’s what defines us as man or woman.
Language is based upon definition…so are we going to change the definition of a man or woman? I could care less if we do or don’t…I’m just curious.
less
As the daughter of a transwoman, let me see if I can clarify this a bit. What you've described, the physiological elements, is the person's sex (female, male, etc). The way they identify is their gender (man, woman, and a whole slew of others). This is often confusing to people because, for the majority of the population, their gender and sex match up; these people are sometimes referred to as "cisgendered". People whose gender identity does not match up with their physiology are sometimes called "transgendered", "transsexual", or just "trans" (the most inclusive, least likely to offend term). Because they so often match up, most people end up using sex and gender interchangeably when they are in fact different concepts.
It's not so much a case of changing the definition of "man" or "woman" as it is being more precise in our terminology. Man and Woman refer to gender identifications, as do Boi, Grrl, and Queer. Male, female, and the intersex spectrum are some examples of sex. This can be very confusing for people used to using gender and sex interchangeably.
Here's an example to illustrate. My transgendered parent was born with a body that was physiologically male (the sex). However, she was also born with a the mind of a girl, now a woman (the gender identity). She identifies as a woman, and is undergoing a medical transition to make her body match up with who she is "inside." This does not mean that she is a man that identifies as a woman. This makes her a male-bodied person who identifies as a woman.
I hope I've been able to help clear up the confusion.