Quote:
I don't want to overstep my boundaries or anything, but I don't think this is something that should be an issue for battle with evidence and retorts and refutes.
Originally posted by
NewEnglandCouple
Good call, I'm going to point that out the next time she uses this argument.
I don't know if I would say that she's trying to "weasel out" or make an excuse. If she is, then there are bigger issues at hand - she might not feel comfortable in the relationship, she might not be feeling satisfied, there might be health issues and she's not really enjoying it/interested in it. If that's the case, then seeing a doctor or a psychologist might be something to consider.
However, it could also be that she really does think she can smell the semen. It's not rational, but it's what she believes. It's something that she's conscious of and it's not just going to go away because it's a "silly" thought.
The whole "period blood" thing is certainly a good argument and it could very well make her realize her idea is kind of silly. On the other hand, it could make her become more and self-conscious when she's going through that time of the month and she COULD start to miss work because of it.
I obviously don't know her or what he thought processes or motives are behind it, but this is all stuff to consider. What might be irrational or simply untrue might hold a lot of value for someone who believes in it. If she thinks it smells, she's going to find some way of confirming in herself that it does indeed smell.