Quote:
That would be nice but since we don't know who voted what, you wouldn't know which comment was for the crappy vote (unless it was the first vote on the review).
Originally posted by
mjtheprincess
This is kinda related to kendra30752 and sktb0007's comments...I would really like a "why" feature added to the review voting. I don't mind receiving a "useful" vote...but I wish there was some sort of requirement that
...
more
This is kinda related to kendra30752 and sktb0007's comments...I would really like a "why" feature added to the review voting. I don't mind receiving a "useful" vote...but I wish there was some sort of requirement that made it so when you vote you have to also give your reasoning for the vote. I don't know if this is possible, but it sure would be helpful for those trying to improve their review skills. I know I certainly look up to some of the top reviewers on the site, and I would love to be able to improve my reviews when they aren't rated as fantastic...
less
I actually received a "somewhat useful" vote from someone, and I happened to be online when it happened so I know who casted the vote. They then left a comment something like, "Thanks so much!!!!" So basically, if I wasn't online at the time, I wouldn't have known they made the crappy vote because from there comment, they make it seem like I helped them. I've also seen people vote on reviews (the first vote to the review), where they say basically the same thing "thank you so much!!!" but then give a terribly bad vote. I can see this being a mistake SOMETIMES but it should be rare... or at least less often than I see it happening.