Dear Mr. Sexsmith,
I feel very comfortable with being a lesbian, but I'm still really shy and unconfident about being submissive and interested in kink. I'm basically terrified that every woman that I date is going to think that I'm crazy, or be unable to top me because it goes against their general morals. I'm sure I'll feel better about this once I get older (I'm 18 and still haven't dated any girls), but for now it would be really great to be able to come into this identity without feeling guilty about what this means for me as a feminist that preaches nonviolence against women, yet wants to be spanked in the bedroom.
—Ali
—Ali
Dear Ali:
You’re right — your feelings about this will change as you get older. Not necessarily because of age inherently, but because as you get older, you’ll have more experiences. You’ll date girls, you’ll have some sex the way you want to, you’ll probably have some sex in ways that weren’t your ideal way but that were still useful and through which you’ll learn a lot.
Meanwhile, though, here’s some ideas to start chewing on.
You gotta start chipping away at that internalized guilt about the supposed “conflict” between being spanked (or receiving any kind of physical sensation in the bedroom) and feminist theories of nonviolence. BDSM, kink, and sensation play are not violence. Violence is defined as “Behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something,” and while yes, sensation play is done to cause pain, it is not done with the intention of hurting or damaging someone. In fact, the intention is the opposite: it comes from loving care, from consensual exploration. Okay, maybe it doesn’t always come from loving care, but in an ideal world I believe it would.
The Lesbian Sex Mafia, a BDSM education and social group in New York City which has been running since 1981, has a great document called BDSM is Not Abuse. Abuse and violence aren’t the same thing, but I think many of their comparisons apply to violence, as well. For example:
— After an SM scene, the people involved usually feel good. After a violent act, the people involved usually feel bad.
And:
— Negotiation occurs before an SM scene to determine what will and will not happen in that scene. In a violent act, one person determines what will happen.
The key difference that separates a violent act from a kinky or BDSM exploration is consent. All parties consent to being involved, all parties have some knowledge of the parameters of what could happen, and all parties consent that they have the skills to be able to deal with the potential difficulties of playing with edgy things.
The people you date may or may not judge you for being submissive and kinky in the bedroom, that’s true — I won’t pretend no one will judge you. Dating is hard, and putting yourself out there with your desires is a vulnerable position. But remember: vulnerability comes from strength, not weakness. It takes strength to put yourself out there honestly. It is a risk to show your true colors because you could be laughed at or dismissed or called crazy. But the rewards are massive: You may find someone with whom you could play.
There are many, many skilled tops out there who would love to take you down, show you the ropes, and explore with you as you’re continuing to discover what it is you like and what really works for you.
I hope that helps begin to undo some of the terror you’re feeling. Part of why it is terrifying to reconcile being a feminist and being a kinky bottom is because there is a real stigma in lesbian worlds against kink and against giving up power as a submissive, particularly because there is a lot of second-wave feminist theories that our communities are based around, like the idea that we must always be equal and never above or below each other in the bedroom. But there are also many, many communities which will help you explore the submission and the bottoming, and there is much room for overlap, and there are a lot of people inside the lesbian and queer worlds who have done a lot of this work already.
All kinks, all fetishes, are born from conflict — it is rare to have fetishized a scenario which is completely, one hundred percent all good (or one hundred percent all bad). I know for example one of the reasons I have a gender fetish is because I spend so much of my time studying gender, experiencing the ways that my own non-normative gender gets marginalized and devalued in this culture, and listening and working with other people’s gender pinprick moments; moments which aren’t sledgehammers of wrongness but little pricks of violence and anger. It works for me — one of them feeds the other.
Inside the conflict, there is heat. Friction. Tension. Spark. And that’s what you need for a good fetish. The trick is to figure out how to reconcile the conflict for yourself, which is a process that may take a lifetime. It’s a real conflict, but it’s one that can generate tons of use, in an erotic life.
A couple more final things I highly recommend:
• Listen to the Savage Love Podcast. Sure, there are many problematic things about what Dan Savage says (he can be transphobic, fatphobic, and sexist, for example), but he has incredibly good advice about getting what you want in bed and being unapologetic about your fetishes and kinks.
• Read The Topping Book and The Bottoming Book by Easton & Hardy. Much of my own philosophies about topping and bottoming come from these books and they’re brilliant, clear, easy to read, and spot on.
• Find a local BDSM club! They probably exist in your area, or nearby. Visit clubs in other cities next time you are on a vacation — Visit the Lesbian Sex Mafia next time you’re in New York City, we have workshops open to members and non-members alike on the third Friday of every month.
• Get on Fetlife.com and start finding folks like you in your area for dates, parties, workshops, and more. Go to events. Go to a play party, if you’ve got one nearby. Join all the groups you can find on Fetlife for your region and in your interests, and start talking to more people about your interests. There are great BDSM theory groups, submissive groups, queer groups — anything and everything you can imagine.
Keep working on that “I’m basically terrified” thing. You don’t have to be terrified. There’s a huge world of people out there who love playing with sensation, power, and intensity in the bedroom, and there’s someone for you.
Meanwhile, though, here’s some ideas to start chewing on.
You gotta start chipping away at that internalized guilt about the supposed “conflict” between being spanked (or receiving any kind of physical sensation in the bedroom) and feminist theories of nonviolence. BDSM, kink, and sensation play are not violence. Violence is defined as “Behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something,” and while yes, sensation play is done to cause pain, it is not done with the intention of hurting or damaging someone. In fact, the intention is the opposite: it comes from loving care, from consensual exploration. Okay, maybe it doesn’t always come from loving care, but in an ideal world I believe it would.
The Lesbian Sex Mafia, a BDSM education and social group in New York City which has been running since 1981, has a great document called BDSM is Not Abuse. Abuse and violence aren’t the same thing, but I think many of their comparisons apply to violence, as well. For example:
— After an SM scene, the people involved usually feel good. After a violent act, the people involved usually feel bad.
And:
— Negotiation occurs before an SM scene to determine what will and will not happen in that scene. In a violent act, one person determines what will happen.
The key difference that separates a violent act from a kinky or BDSM exploration is consent. All parties consent to being involved, all parties have some knowledge of the parameters of what could happen, and all parties consent that they have the skills to be able to deal with the potential difficulties of playing with edgy things.
The people you date may or may not judge you for being submissive and kinky in the bedroom, that’s true — I won’t pretend no one will judge you. Dating is hard, and putting yourself out there with your desires is a vulnerable position. But remember: vulnerability comes from strength, not weakness. It takes strength to put yourself out there honestly. It is a risk to show your true colors because you could be laughed at or dismissed or called crazy. But the rewards are massive: You may find someone with whom you could play.
Mr. Sexsmith Recommends:
I hope that helps begin to undo some of the terror you’re feeling. Part of why it is terrifying to reconcile being a feminist and being a kinky bottom is because there is a real stigma in lesbian worlds against kink and against giving up power as a submissive, particularly because there is a lot of second-wave feminist theories that our communities are based around, like the idea that we must always be equal and never above or below each other in the bedroom. But there are also many, many communities which will help you explore the submission and the bottoming, and there is much room for overlap, and there are a lot of people inside the lesbian and queer worlds who have done a lot of this work already.
All kinks, all fetishes, are born from conflict — it is rare to have fetishized a scenario which is completely, one hundred percent all good (or one hundred percent all bad). I know for example one of the reasons I have a gender fetish is because I spend so much of my time studying gender, experiencing the ways that my own non-normative gender gets marginalized and devalued in this culture, and listening and working with other people’s gender pinprick moments; moments which aren’t sledgehammers of wrongness but little pricks of violence and anger. It works for me — one of them feeds the other.
Inside the conflict, there is heat. Friction. Tension. Spark. And that’s what you need for a good fetish. The trick is to figure out how to reconcile the conflict for yourself, which is a process that may take a lifetime. It’s a real conflict, but it’s one that can generate tons of use, in an erotic life.
A couple more final things I highly recommend:
• Listen to the Savage Love Podcast. Sure, there are many problematic things about what Dan Savage says (he can be transphobic, fatphobic, and sexist, for example), but he has incredibly good advice about getting what you want in bed and being unapologetic about your fetishes and kinks.
• Read The Topping Book and The Bottoming Book by Easton & Hardy. Much of my own philosophies about topping and bottoming come from these books and they’re brilliant, clear, easy to read, and spot on.
• Find a local BDSM club! They probably exist in your area, or nearby. Visit clubs in other cities next time you are on a vacation — Visit the Lesbian Sex Mafia next time you’re in New York City, we have workshops open to members and non-members alike on the third Friday of every month.
• Get on Fetlife.com and start finding folks like you in your area for dates, parties, workshops, and more. Go to events. Go to a play party, if you’ve got one nearby. Join all the groups you can find on Fetlife for your region and in your interests, and start talking to more people about your interests. There are great BDSM theory groups, submissive groups, queer groups — anything and everything you can imagine.
Keep working on that “I’m basically terrified” thing. You don’t have to be terrified. There’s a huge world of people out there who love playing with sensation, power, and intensity in the bedroom, and there’s someone for you.
Comments