That old ditty from childhood, the one most of us recall humming at least once in our love struck youth, could easily be applied to the stunning news in December about “The Berlin patient” who, post-treatment for leukemia, was cleared of his HIV: “The cure works. The cure does not. The cure works. The cure does not…”
Predictably, the media jumped to share the news. Experts ‘blown away’ by HIV cure case, wrote the Sydney Morning Herald. CNN reported that, Researchers Report Possible HIV Infection Cure, and our own Lorna D. Keach wrote a balanced review of the story in Berlin Patient Cured of HIV: Breakthrough stem cell treatment gives hope to millions.
After a few days of reading about this story, most of us were left wondering if the news was overstated or premature. The likelihood is that, as with many stories involving scientific advances, particularly when it comes to topics that arouse public concern, scientists talk one way, the pundits spin another, and the art and soul of research is misunderstood along the way.
Predictably, the media jumped to share the news. Experts ‘blown away’ by HIV cure case, wrote the Sydney Morning Herald. CNN reported that, Researchers Report Possible HIV Infection Cure, and our own Lorna D. Keach wrote a balanced review of the story in Berlin Patient Cured of HIV: Breakthrough stem cell treatment gives hope to millions.
After a few days of reading about this story, most of us were left wondering if the news was overstated or premature. The likelihood is that, as with many stories involving scientific advances, particularly when it comes to topics that arouse public concern, scientists talk one way, the pundits spin another, and the art and soul of research is misunderstood along the way.
Have an STD? you are not alone.Find others with same STD at site named STDRomance. you may be upset and think your sex life is over. However, once you settle down and learn the facts, you'll realize that having STD is not the end of the world, and it's not the end of your social life.
There are so many "gems" of wisdom and good writing in this piece! "The likelihood is that, as with many stories involving scientific advances, particularly when it comes to topics that arouse public concern, scientists talk one way, the pundits spin another, and the art and soul of research is misunderstood along the way" and "that is the beauty and art of science. Just when you think there’s no new way to look at a challenge, something astonishing occurs" ... and of course the Ratatouille quote. In the HIV field (which I work in) many have become cynical and pessimistic about finding a cure, but I still believe in the "magic" of science, which isn't really magic at all ... just "so much more to discover". Thanks for this great piece.
Hi Janet - You are MOST WELCOME. I really enjoyed writing this, because as a self-declared science geek, I love making this stuff more available to the general audience. I'm not expert AT ALL in HIV research, so it was also great fun learning more about the current state of affairs in this area of research. Peace out! T