Votes for the editor should be based on the spelling, grammar, capitalization, and punctuation in a review. These votes help Eden determine if an editor is consistent in their proofreading and good enough to be in the Proofreading Program. If you found no errors while reading, the editor did an 'excellent' job. If you found one error or a few areas that were questionable, but overall the review was well read, the editor did a 'good' job. If you found two or more obvious errors, the editor did a 'poor' job