I'm a fan of EdenFantasys regular water-based lube. However, it is a bit viscous and on the runny side if you are lathering up a toy for anal. Which is what we most often use lube for. But the Cheeky Anal Lube solved the problem. It is still a bit runny, and it's not quite as solid as a gel. But it has significantly more holding power and does not just run right off the tip of the toy as the regular water-based lube does, which does make it more suitable for using anally.

They both have the exact same ingredient profile, so presumably, they just shifted the ratios to thicken it up. Works great, is reasonably long-lasting, and relatively odorless. It's a win!