One reason why I bought Boy Butter was because of the claim that it is easy to clean off. That claim seems pretty accurate. I bought the 16oz tub and I kind of regret it. No fault to the packaging or anything, but I didn't realize exactly how large the 16oz tub is. The tub itself seems a little unsanitary compared to a squeeze bottle (although Boy Butter does sell the squeeze bottle, which would be my recommendation). Instead of using the main tub, I just found a small plastic container and scooped some into it with a spoon.

When I first opened the tub, I was in for quite a surprise. The product looked like it was a soft vegetable shortening and I was a bit nervous about applying it to my penis. Usually oil is a pain to clean off and requires a bunch of soap and water. I was pleasantly surprised that the product really did clean off very well with just water, though. It does take a little more effort to clean off than water-based lube, but not by much.

Comparing to water-based lube, it’s amazing. Boy Butter just feels silkier and slicker. It also feels more natural than some of the water-based lubes that I’ve used in the past. It doesn’t really dry out fast like water-based lubes. You go through a lot less lube with Boy Butter just because you don’t have to constantly reapply it and really all you need is a quarter-sized dab.

Since it is an oil based lube, you can’t use it with condoms, which is unfortunate. I’ve yet to try it internally with any of my plugs and I probably won’t. I would imagine it would work quite well as an anal lube, but I can imagine it can be a pain to clean out with anything short of an enema. So far I’ve only used it for masturbating and with my girlfriend for handjobs and I love it for those roles.