To be honest, I'm still a little torn on this. I hadn't used up the whole packet when I wrote the review and I tucked the packet into the little drawer that holds all the rest of my lube. I was digging through there for something else and stumbled back on this lube packet. Surprisingly enough even though it was "open" the whole time it hadn't dried out at all. So I gave it another shot. I squeezed about half of what was left onto my arm to test it out and make sure it was still good, and while quickly rubbing it around my arm I saw the foaming that other reviews had mentioned. I was ok with that, and tried it again with my husband and I'm left with the same impression I had before; that it's good for starting out but not if you need lube the whole time. While that works fine for me, I doubt I'll be buying any more in the future because I have so many other lubes that work just as well or better.