I read a review before buying this so I knew it was supposed to be larger than the average compact, but I was still surprised to see it in person. It looks huge. My first impression was that this is perfect. Large size, beautiful colors that look like they'd work perfectly for my skin. I was ecstatic and whipped out my brush set right then. Since this is also made for use on the body, I thought well, this will last forever since I only use bronzer on my face.
Upon further inspection, I found that this isn't actually much bigger than your typical Physician's Formula brand. This is a wide compact, but if you look at the depth of the product you're getting, it measures about a quarter inch deep and almost 4" wide.
My Physician's Formula container is smaller in width, but it's deeper. You see what I'm getting at? You're not actually getting that much more product. This beauty bronzer is Net Wt. 37.31g/1.316 OZ. I was extremely disappointed for a few reasons. 1. It's a whopping $22 for a bronzer that does not have $22 quality, but since it was so much larger than any other bronzer, I was happy to spend an extra 10 minutes trying to get the application just right. So when I realized that I'm really not getting that much more bronzer, only a wider package, I had to face the quality. If I'm going to pay $22, I'm just going to go for a good quality one since I'm not actually getting that much more than I do with my $11 Physician's Formula.
Here is where I dug a chunk out, to measure the depth of actual product. In this photo you can also see what I meant by the silver plate that holds the product & sits in the compact.
Combine that with the fact that Physician's Formula (and most) bronzers come with a decent applicator (and mirror, but hey, I won't be greedy) it's really not an exciting product.
The first time I applied this bronzer, it was in the darkest corner of my house -- where my vanity sets. This is bad because I never know just how much makeup I'm wearing until I get in the bathroom. It was way too much. My biggest problem is that this stuff has red undertones and instead of having the pretty blend of white highlighter, gold shimmer and brown brozing/tanning powder, I have a super red face. Just look at my photos. It's laughable! I look wild. In the photos, I'm wearing one light swipe, which I used with my soft flat-top brush since a real blush brush applied about double. I have to be very careful and even days later, I have trouble and have to wipe a lot of it off.
I don't mind a little peachy tint in my makeup since it looks nice on my cheeks, but this is full-blown orange! I tried the brown, gold and white on my eyelids and even that looks awful. I believe the pigment in this is just way off period. Using the brown on my eyelids looked like I had been beaten! The gold was OK, but it's impossible to get only gold without the brown/red. The white was best for using as eyeshadow, and I like it, but can only use the tiniest amount or else brown gets on my brush.
I want to compare to the other products I had used as bronzer, highlighter and eyeshadow (all similar to this bronzer).
Here's what products we're comparing:
1. An organic gold eyeshadow with green undertones pictured right below my wrist bone. It's the most different from the other colors. This one is also pictured in the left lower corner of the Bella Bronzer.
I like this, but prefer a plain gold, especially a metallic gold. This has the green undertones making it less than a perfect choice when I want highlights and gold eyelids. It is a mineral shadow and is more pigmented & shimmery than Bella. It also stays on longer. Again, if there was enough layer of white & gold in Bella, I'd be much happier with it and it wouldn't have rated the lowest of my collection.
2.
A very old gold eyeshadow I've had since I was a freshman in highschool -- 6 years ago & it's stuck around with regular use. I kept using this old stuff because I still haven't found the gold shadow I've been looking for and this comes close. Plus, I can use it as a highlighter. It's creamy, but always ends up in my creases. This shadow is what I have on my eyelids in my photos. It's pictured right next to my pinky knuckle -- the lightest shade on my hand. In the photo above, with the Bella Bronzer and the small shadow & bronzer, the Avon gold is the small jar in the right lower corner. I like the white in Bella Bronzer better than this because I can use it as a highlighter without it creasing or running. However, this gold is more shimmery than Bella's gold, so I prefer it for coloring my eyes. If it wasn't for the red color showing through (due to lack of enough white and gold being included in the compact) in the white & gold of the Bella Bronzer, I would have far less issues with it.
3.
A cheap, drugstore eyeshadow/bronzer. It's pictured right under the knuckle next to my index finger. This one has the most shimmer compared to the others. It has similar, but more subtle undertones as the Bella Bronzer. It's more pigmented than Bella and costs less than $2.99. You can see it's a loose powder. This isn't my favorite because it too contains subtle red undertones. It doesn't show up like Bella does though. I used this previous to buying the Bella Bronzer and using two swipes gives me a subtle, natural glow. My most preferred is Physician's Formula, which contains no red undertones.
4. Bella Bronzer.
This is the one pictured under my index finger knuckle. It's the least shimmery of the bunch and is extremely red. I swiped my widest shadow brush through all three colors in the Bella and blended onto my hand.