I've said in my other reviews that the Sex in a Can line is a perfect starting point for anyone trying to get into the Fleshlight line without spending full price on the full-sized model. They're also great for men with more average penis sizes to enjoy the full range of the more complex textures. Being smaller and tighter, the Sex in a Can series doesn't ask you to be packing a whole lot to enjoy a Fleshlight. The O'Doyle's Stout, though, may be a bit too much even for average sized guys.

Tightness is a great feature for a Fleshlight to have. As the Sex in a Can model meant to emulate anal sex, the tightness is a key part of the design. However, I found it to be almost too much. The tightness of the product was overwhelming, to the point where it became almost hard to feel the intricacies of the texture because of how tight it was, and this was without the end cap on and no suction. I have a fairly average girth and had no problems with the Sukit or Lady Lager, but the O'Doyle's Stout was a bit much. Those who consider themselves to be "girthy" should probably steer clear of the O'Doyle's Stout.

Those who can deal with the tightness will find a satisfying, if unremarkable texture inside. Not as detailed and complex as the Lady Lager or Sukit Draft, the texture is still an interesting one. It is a shrunken down version of the Forbidden texture, and is great for those wanting to recreate the feeling of anal sex. As a man who has not experienced the real deal, it matched what I imagine anal sex to feel like, right down to the incredible tightness. The two other Sex in a Can fleshlight will allow you to squeeze through the opening at half mast. The Stout requires your full attention to squeeze through the front door. After a series of ridges at the immediate entrance, the wavy canal is a real treat. The overwhelming tightness impeded the enjoyment on a few sessions, however, and I actually found it preferable to use the sleeve outside of the case to alleviate some of the tightness issues. This problem will vary depending on how girthy you actually are.

If tightness is the bottom line and something you are looking for, then the O'Doyle Stout is definitely the fleshlight you want to buy. For me, though, it is the runt of the litter for Sex in a Can. The other two provide a more enjoyable experience that allows you to control the tightness, as opposed to the always tight O'Doyle Stout. Again, not every man will experience it that way, but the girthy will want to take that into account before ordering.