I got this for my guy, though it's for both of us to be honest! [It arrived when I was 9 months preggo... need I say more?]

We both like that it's clear versus colored- it allowed him to play more freely without feeling odd about another vagina, and it didn't startle me nearly as much when I came across it again with the top off in our closet! We also felt that it allowed cleaning a bit more thoroughly- he could see if it dried or was thoroughly rinsed.

The smell was very very light, so that was a definite positive. It felt quite sticky when we received it, and this feeling remains even after cleaning [you know how sometimes it can turn gummy? Not this one], but once lubricant was added it was soft and supple, no stickiness at all. I was surprised by the weight of the toy- both in the canister and out. Quite a fun and odd feeling, grasping the inner alone [the almost gooey, weird soft clear tube instead the canister]
I licked it though it wasn't intended for this, and no taste I could decipher.

I'm not sure if it's the materials on the clear version, but he felt it was a bit soft initially. He tried taking it out of its case, and using it as a sleeve [with his hand applying pressure], but said that it softened the effect and was too floppy. He experimented with blocking the hole at the end, as the screw cap didn't allow this properly [we added plastic, and then took it off and blocked with his hand, and said that it increased the pleasure, though the noise of using the toy also increased.
He wasn't 100% sold at first, but he's used it a couple of times since. He says it does feel really good, but the negatives outweigh the positives.

Downsides were:
-cleaning: really hard to get it to dry, and trying to turn it inside out, as soft as flexible as it is you'd think it might be able to, tears the openings.
-big. Heavy. [This coming from an over 6' guy that's a solid 220 of muscle. He's no lightweight!]
-hard to store [for us anyway, took up a significant portion of our fun box, and definitely not able to be stored in a bedside table in our house!]
-noisy when giving the suction needed


I asked him if he'd recommend it:
"No."
"What! Why?"
"Too big and heavy. I liked the hand one more." [note: he was referring to this one: https://www.edenfantasys.com/masturbators/masturbation-sleeves/sue-johansons-head-honcho ]

So there you have it, from the man of few words. It's good for some fun once in awhile, but not his fave. He wouldn't buy again.