I have heard so much about pony play from my friends and fellow online buddies, but never actually did it myself. I might have swallowed more then I can handle with this being my first.

The butt plug is not "small" and I myself had to take a moment just to get it all in, so this is not for first timers. If you have never used a butt plug before I do not think this is for you, I highly suggest you look else where as this is for people who have played with the back door before. Once I got this frisky toy in it stayed in with no issue and I had no worries it would just slip out. With the butt plug made of rubber it is still firm, yet still squishy for more comfort. The tail is made of what seems to be nylon. If you leave the tail bunched up or bent for too long it will hold that pose for awhile before straightening out. I had no issue with it fraying; they are well bunched together.

My Pony Play butt plug came curled up so I had to let it lay out before giving it a full test. As a whip, this toy is a joke! With a sting that my dog would hardly feel and with the butt plug as the handle, it makes the accuracy not all that great.

Storage for this toy will be a pain. If you plan to use it on the regular then you will need to find a place to store it without the tail curling up. If you only want to use it on occasion, I guess it would be OK because you could take it out in advance to let it straighten out. Personally, that seems like something I don't like to do - spontaneous is my middle name!

The rubber is smooth and clean, with no seams so clean up is easy. Rubber is porous so I would not recommend sharing this toy with anyone. Simple warm water and antibacterial soap will work for this toy, that is what I used.

I really had a fun time with this toy! For my first time, it met all my expectations.

My dog got a hold of the tail end of my toy and some of the threads came out! Other then that it is still the same and holds up well!