I’m very new to any kind of anal play. And when I say new, I mean nothing and no one has ever ventured into that area. But I’ve always been intrigued by the idea, so I was really excited, and a bit apprehensive, to test out the Small Butt Plug|Anal plugs: Small butt plug by Topco-Hustler.

When my toy arrived, I eagerly tore open the packaging to find a cute, not at all intimidating little butt plug waiting for me. It’s quite a pretty toy; purple with pearl colored swirls through it. It’s silicone, which means it’s non porous and easy to clean and can be boiled for up to three minutes to sterilize it. It’s also incredibly soft and oh so touchable. And though it’s not a listed feature, I found the base works well as a suction cup for some hands free play.

After squishing the plug in my hands for a while, I searched through the packaging for what I realized was missing. I was dismayed to find that the plug did not come with a sample of lube as the description and picture described. I was running low on water based lube, but I figured “Oh well.” I needed to buy some more anyway.

Once I had bought some water based lube, I waited for my husband to go to bed to try out my new toy. Being my first experience with any kind of anal play, I wanted to try it out by myself.

I got myself warmed up and decided it was time to find out what I had been missing. I lubed up the butt plug and my ass and slowly started to slide it in. There was some resistance, but I liked the feeling I was getting as the plug slid into that untouched area. Soon the whole plug, aside from the flared base, was in my ass.

Having the toy in place made me wetter than ever, and I loved feeling so full. I got out my favorite vibrator and quickly brought myself to a very nice orgasm; a quicker and stronger one than I tend to have.

After my first run with the plug, I washed it off with soap and warm water and put it away. The next day while my husband was at work, I tried it out again. This time, I left it in for a while to see how it felt. This is how I found the plug’s flaws, though they’re minor ones.

When I tried sitting down or just walking around with it in for a few minutes, the plug started digging into and hurting my butt cheeks. And although I am new to this, after a while, I couldn’t feel the plug very well anymore; a potential problem.

Overall, this is a high quality butt plug perfect for any anal beginner and well worth the price. It’ll be in my toy box for years to come, or until I need a bigger one, whichever comes first.