I think this kit would be great for someone just starting to explore anal play, or even someone with a little experience who's ready to try new shapes and stuff. The silicone is great, very smooth and not too soft or firm. The suction base can make for interesting showers (water based jelly lubes are great for these toys.) These are good for solo sessions or with a partner, but don't be shocked if someone has to hold it in place. I got the black one to stay in for a while, but the other two just don't have enough of a neck to really function as a plug.

The purple one would probably be best for someone new to anal toys. The tip is very thin and soft, and the taper is pretty gradual. I'm not a fan because I think it's a little too thin, making it a feel kind of pointy once it's inserted. It's also the longest of the three, which adds to the feeling of being poked, I think. I like this one for warming up, or for just a little anal play during other activities, if one of us has a free hand.

I liked the black one best. It has a nice curved shape that gave a great feeling of fullness, without being uncomfortable. It's soft (but not too soft,) and it can, sort of, function as a plug. I wouldn't recommend any sex position where your butt is in the air, but spooning or missionary might work, if you're careful. I think the kit was worth buying just for this toy and I use it alone and with my husband.

The pink one was a bit harder than I expected it to be, but the tip was still flexible. I think I would save this one until you're more comfortable with anal play, because of the bumps. I'm not a big fan of the bumps, but they're not unpleasant.

My only real complaint is something unavoidable with silicone (or, at least it has been with all of my silicone toys so far) and that's lint. These things will attract lint and hair like crazy, so I keep them in a zippered freezer bag. It might not be a fancy storage solution, but it does keep them clean.

All in all, this is a great kit and an amazing price. If you don't know if anal is for you, but you're curious, I think this is a wonderful place to start.