The New Intimacy

Featured by EdenFantasys

Emperor
Emperor
Oversized realistic dildo with balls
Atlant
Booty overloader
Booty overloader
Oversized glass butt plug

Finally Breaking the Size Barrier

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
This is kinda a follow up/revision discussion to one I’d posted awhile back. So it I seemed I’d hit a wall and couldn’t get past getting anything in over 1 1/4” diameter, but after forever and a day, I finally graduated to a 1 1/2” diameter plug

So this made me wonder how long it took others to size up and what their favorite comfortable size of anal toy is.
01/18/2023
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Robin Goodfellow Robin Goodfellow
Congrats! A few months of almost daily training to break the +2" toys/ fisting. With very minimal maintenance that has been easy to jump back up to when the mood arises for many years.
01/18/2023
Contributor: Arianne Arianne
Quote:
Originally posted by SoloRebel
This is kinda a follow up/revision discussion to one I’d posted awhile back. So it I seemed I’d hit a wall and couldn’t get past getting anything in over 1 1/4” diameter, but after forever and a day, I finally graduated to a 1 1/2” diameter plug ... more
Still experimenting, but am becoming averse to whatever causes bleeding and hemorrhoids. I've noticed that for me stretching does both, so I'm not interested in going back to cucumbers. Now I'm going for shape instead of size: sharp going in, blunt coming out. In other words, heart-shaped with very small hearts at the start. Would like to find that in anal beads as a machine.
01/18/2023
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Robin Goodfellow
Congrats! A few months of almost daily training to break the +2" toys/ fisting. With very minimal maintenance that has been easy to jump back up to when the mood arises for many years.
Thanks…that extra fullness feels freaking awesome! I imagine +2”/fisting would be a blast off to some erotic galaxy for sure! Curious enough; maybe I’ll get there someday. How would you compare 1 1/2” to 2”? Anal play is and always has been quite the feel good obsession ever since that first curious finger poke years ago…always wanting more! Sizing up to 1 1/2” has definitely increased the toy selection options to expand and experiment with new butt stuff I’ve been curious to try!
01/20/2023
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Arianne
Still experimenting, but am becoming averse to whatever causes bleeding and hemorrhoids. I've noticed that for me stretching does both, so I'm not interested in going back to cucumbers. Now I'm going for shape instead of size: sharp going ... more
Yeah, definitely don’t want anything too big that can cause injury. Start small, go slow and use plenty of lube! The standard tapered butt plug with a flared base always works for me!
01/20/2023
Contributor: Robin Goodfellow Robin Goodfellow
Quote:
Originally posted by SoloRebel
Thanks…that extra fullness feels freaking awesome! I imagine +2”/fisting would be a blast off to some erotic galaxy for sure! Curious enough; maybe I’ll get there someday. How would you compare 1 1/2” to 2”? Anal play is and always has been quite the ... more
You're welcome.

I found increasing to the 2" range (when you are ready) is incredibly fulfilling. From 1.5" to 2" was like leveling up, to maximum fulfillment.

From 1 7/8" to 2 3/8" is the sweet spot for my body. With 2" to 2 1/4" being my go to. Even the tiny step up from there to 2 3/8" requires me to do adequate re-training and a lot more time investment for a session. So I don't do it much.

We bought and reviewed a Jet Annihilator and on Edens which is 3" diameter. It's a cool toy but requires such warm up training we don't use it much. Maybe someday 3" will become our new 2", but not so far.

I highly recommend the Jet Black Jack for the next stage of your journey. It is inexpensive and a wonderfully designed toy. The first bead is the largest, and if you make it over that you are home free.
01/22/2023
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Robin Goodfellow
You're welcome.I found increasing to the 2" range (when you are ready) is incredibly fulfilling. From 1.5" to 2" was like leveling up, to maximum fulfillment. From 1 7/8" to 2 3/8" is the sweet spot for my body. With ... more
Well stated…it’s definitely a journey. I’ll just take my time and enjoy every ride! The Jet Black Jack looks great.

Good luck with the 3”. I guess that why it’s called the Annihilator.
02/22/2023
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Robin Goodfellow
Congrats! A few months of almost daily training to break the +2" toys/ fisting. With very minimal maintenance that has been easy to jump back up to when the mood arises for many years.
So in the few months since this post, steady and consistent play with the 1.50” plug, it’s become my new goto! Perhaps I need to keep up the momentum and level up to 1.75” real soon!
04/17/2023
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
Quote:
Originally posted by Robin Goodfellow
Congrats! A few months of almost daily training to break the +2" toys/ fisting. With very minimal maintenance that has been easy to jump back up to when the mood arises for many years.
UPDATE…Since that April post..tonight I finally leveled up to the 1.75”! The extra fullness feels freaking awesome! Got my eye on 2” now!!!
06/15/2023