Hormonal Birth Control DOESN'T Cause Breast Cancer?!

Contributor: aliceinthehole aliceinthehole
so i was recently at my gyno's discussing BC options and for the millionth time told the nurse who checked me out before seeing the doc of my reasons for not being on BC. my mom's had breast cancer and has tested positive for 4 out of the 5 BRCA genes she was tested for. this means i'm pretty damn likely to have it in my genes from her side.

and from all i've heard regarding hormonal birth control, it increases your chance of breast cancer. the nurse agreed, as i knew she would.


when i got into the gyno, a lady i'd never seen at this clinic before (i don't really go on a regular basis and it's planned parenthood, so they have lots of docs and they're often switching out) she was ADAMANT that this was false information.


she said it was a myth that was started to keep women off birth control and promote the abstinence movement. she said there is NO scientific study that proves this. she said if you have HAD breast cancer and/or are over 50, you should not take it. but for me, she said hormones were fine.


i told her the nurse, as well as anyone else i'd ever spoken with about the subject, had agreed with me. hormonal birth control and those at risk for breast cancer do not mix. she got her feathers ruffled, marched right outside and gave the nurse a talking to.


does anyone else have hard evidence other than hearsay that hormonal BC causes breast cancer?
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
i have heard that hormonal BC causes breast cancer
11
i have heard that hormonal BC does NOT cause breast cancer
6
i have hard evidence that it does. i'll explain below.
i have hard evidence that it does not. i'll explain below.
1
Total votes: 18 (14 voters)
Poll is closed
11/30/2011
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Beck Beck
link

I did not really read this, but thought it would help you.
11/30/2011
Contributor: Rarity Rarity
I would say that you should look into this very thoroughly before deciding on one option since there is a history of breast cancer in your family. There have been studies done on the subject but most of them seem a little old and may be outdated. From what I've skimmed through, there seems to be a slightly elevated risk for women who are on oral contraceptives. Since the levels of estrogen in the pills are lower than they were when the pill was first introduced, they may be safer but I don't know if it is necessarily safe for you to take.

You may be interested in reading this particular study that focuses on the link between oral contraceptives and the incidence of breast cancer in women with a family history of breast cancer.

Additional reading material:
1 2

I don't think this is all bs, quite honestly. It's worth looking into if you're interested in considering hormonal contraception. You should be able to make an informed decision. Good luck!
11/30/2011
Contributor: Ghost Ghost
There is actually a lot of evidence to suggest that the major cause of breast cancer in women is repeated ovulatory cycles, rather than hormonal birth control.
If you are interested, I will write up a small review (based on the actual research) for you as I did on the "importance of virginity" thread. However, most people don't seem appreciate my lit reviews, so I'll only do it if you're interested.
11/30/2011
Contributor: aliceinthehole aliceinthehole
Quote:
Originally posted by Ghost
There is actually a lot of evidence to suggest that the major cause of breast cancer in women is repeated ovulatory cycles, rather than hormonal birth control.
If you are interested, I will write up a small review (based on the actual research) ... more
totally interested! i'll certainly appreciate the effort. thank you.
11/30/2011
Contributor: indiglo indiglo
Elnoa is right. I've spoken to my gyno about this, since I've been on BC since I was a teenager. I had similar concerns, but she assured me that it is safe for me to stay on it right up to menopause. Yay!

I look forward to reading your review too, Elnoa!
11/30/2011
Contributor: Peggi Peggi
There are some links to breast cancer due to hormonal fluctuations due to oral birth control, but the shot and rings thus far have not been linked to it, so that could be an option.
11/30/2011
Contributor: aliceinthehole aliceinthehole
Quote:
Originally posted by Beck
link

I did not really read this, but thought it would help you.
"How do oral contraceptives affect breast cancer risk?

A woman’s risk of developing breast cancer depends on several factors, some of which are related to her natural hormones. Hormonal factors that increase the risk of breast cancer include conditions that may allow high levels of hormones to persist for long periods of time, such as beginning menstruation at an early age (before age 12), experiencing menopause at a late age (after age 55), having a first child after age 30, and not having children at all.

A 1996 analysis of worldwide epidemiologic data conducted by the Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer found that women who were current or recent users of birth control pills had a slightly elevated risk of developing breast cancer. The risk was highest for women who started using OCs as teenagers. However, 10 or more years after women stopped using OCs, their risk of developing breast cancer returned to the same level as if they had never used birth control pills, regardless of family history of breast cancer, reproductive history, geographic area of residence, ethnic background, differences in study design, dose and type of hormone, or duration of use. In addition, breast cancers diagnosed in women after 10 or more years of not using OCs were less advanced than breast cancers diagnosed in women who had never used OCs. To conduct this analysis, the researchers examined the results of 54 studies. The analysis involved 53,297 women with breast cancer and 100,239 women without breast cancer. More than 200 researchers participated in this combined analysis of their original studies, which represented about 90 percent of the epidemiological studies throughout the world that had investigated the possible relationship between OCs and breast cancer (2).

The findings of the Women’s Contraceptive and Reproductive Experiences (Women’s CARE) study were in contrast to those described above. The Women’s CARE study examined the use of OCs as a risk factor for breast cancer in women ages 35 to 64. Researchers interviewed 4,575 women who were diagnosed with breast cancer between 1994 and 1998, and 4,682 women who did not have breast cancer. Investigators collected detailed information about the participants’ use of OCs, reproductive history, health, and family history. The results, which were published in 2002, indicated that current or former use of OCs did not significantly increase the risk of breast cancer. The findings were similar for white and black women. Factors such as longer periods of use, higher doses of estrogen, initiation of OC use before age 20, and OC use by women with a family history of breast cancer were not associated with an increased risk of the disease (3).

In a National Cancer Institute (NCI)-sponsored study published in 2003, researchers examined risk factors for breast cancer among women ages 20 to 34 compared with women ages 35 to 54. Women diagnosed with breast cancer were asked whether they had used OCs for more than 6 months before diagnosis and, if so, whether the most recent use had been within 5 years, 5 to 10 years, or more than 10 years. The results indicated that the risk was highest for women who used OCs within 5 years prior to diagnosis, particularly in the younger group (4). "


this was the most helpful from this. thank you!


so basically no research has been conclusive. because what one study says, the other debunks. odd.
11/30/2011
Contributor: aliceinthehole aliceinthehole
Quote:
Originally posted by Rarity
I would say that you should look into this very thoroughly before deciding on one option since there is a history of breast cancer in your family. There have been studies done on the subject but most of them seem a little old and may be outdated. ... more
wow, that is ALOT of reading material. i did read the first article but the next two were nearly books.

unfortunately, i'm impatient and fidgety. but i think what i've gotten out of this is that there really is no concrete evidence one way or another. more studies need to be made in order to be conclusive.


for the time being, i'm staying off of it. it hasn't done me any harm so far. knock on wood.
11/30/2011
Contributor: mizzmilla mizzmilla
My doctor also told me it no longer causes breast cancer. However when they first came out with it and the hormone levels were much higher than needed she said it caused it back then. When my aunt died of breast cancer in '89 her doctors told my moms family it was most likely caused by her birth control because there was no history of breast cancer, or any type of cancer, in her family
11/30/2011
Contributor: Cherrylane Cherrylane
I have *heard* that it does, however, I don't particularly believe that at all. There was no good evidence on the matter.
11/30/2011
Contributor: Ansley Ansley
I haven't heard one way or another, to be honest. Most of the cancer talk associated with birth control pills/rings/shots is that it prevents ovarian cancer and ovarian cysts.

There are so many factors involved, I bet it would be difficult to actually pinpoint what is causing what.
12/01/2011
Contributor: Beck Beck
Quote:
Originally posted by Peggi
There are some links to breast cancer due to hormonal fluctuations due to oral birth control, but the shot and rings thus far have not been linked to it, so that could be an option.
I think that this is most likely because there has not been enough time to study these.

Reading this, birth control pills were 20years ahead of the other kinds, so they have had more opportunity for studying and for longer periods of time also. That is going to make a huge difference in the way the other hormonal choices are viewed. But, that would mean that they are 20years older and they have had 20 extra years to improve them, rather than the new kinds of hormonal birth controls.
12/01/2011
Contributor: LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by Rarity
I would say that you should look into this very thoroughly before deciding on one option since there is a history of breast cancer in your family. There have been studies done on the subject but most of them seem a little old and may be outdated. ... more
Hmm..interesting. thanks for the links.
12/02/2011