Boobs after having a baby. Breastfeeding vs. Not breastfeeding.

Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
I need opinions from mothers who have breastfed and mothers who have chosen not to breastfeed. My boyfriend says he hopes I never breastfeed because I will lose my perky boobs. My problem with this is that I am under the impression that you still have to pump the milk out at some point, and that is equally problematic.
What do you think?

P.S. I would prefer breastfeeding because it is the healthy, natural way, but I'm willing to do otherwise if I see fit later on.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
No, you do not have to pump if you aren't feeding your child breastmilk.
6
Yes, you will have to pump regardless for your own health.
4
In some cases you will have to pump, but not necessarily.
4
Breastfeeding is better for your child, so who cares?
19
Breastfeeding will be worse on your boobs than pumping or not breastfeeding at all
Your breasts shouldn't be too different.
7
Regardless of breastfeeding decision, your boobs will stretch on their own.
21
Total votes: 61 (30 voters)
Poll is closed
10/31/2012
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
I forgot to add the "save your boobs and get formula" option.
10/31/2012
Contributor: Gracie Gracie
It is my understanding that the most damage/stretching is done during the pregnancy. Breastfeeding is the healthiest way of feeding infants! It is the primary purpose of breasts! While it may not work out for every mother and child it should be seriously considered! I wish P'Gell was here to add her 2 cents! Did you know breast feeding is actually good for your breasts? I actually lowers your risk of breast cancer.
10/31/2012
Contributor: Melan!e Melan!e
Quote:
Originally posted by Gracie
It is my understanding that the most damage/stretching is done during the pregnancy. Breastfeeding is the healthiest way of feeding infants! It is the primary purpose of breasts! While it may not work out for every mother and child it should be ... more
That's true! About lowering your chances of breast cancer. I agree with what Gracie says. I too will be awaiting P'Gell's answer on this thread
10/31/2012
Contributor: Kissy Kissy
You could feed your baby formula. I am all for breastfeeding though. So many benefits like reduced breast cancer, health, and bonding with the baby.
10/31/2012
Contributor: deltalima deltalima
Quote:
Originally posted by hmb12
I forgot to add the "save your boobs and get formula" option.
Haha good one.
10/31/2012
Contributor: married with children married with children
I would do whats best for your child, after all that is part of being a good parent.
10/31/2012
Contributor: travelnurse travelnurse
pumping verses feeding doesn't matter and breast tissue with stretch with age anyway. The pumping is the same action as the child sucking. I breast fed 2 boys for years and it really isn't any different. My son is 21 years old and he has been on antibiotics 3 times in his whole life and my 15 year old also has only been on antibiotics 3 times. I attribute their health to the breastfeeding. And besides formula is expensive as hell!!! The bond that you form with your children from breastfeeding is the best in the world. I miss those days of sitting and nursing my babies!!!
11/01/2012
Contributor: Jesyra Jesyra
There is a shot (I believe) that you can get to stop the milk glands from producing, but breasts are made to feed babies. That's why we have them. The experience is amazing, and regardless of your choice you're still going to have to deal with 3am feedings. From my experience, it's much easier to cuddle the baby to your breast in bed (while half asleep), than to get up, make a bottle, and then feed the baby (and have to get back to sleep yourself!)

Remember that those old wives tales about breastfeeding dragging you down started long before they had bras! And consequently, before they had nursing bras. This might be tmi, but I'm a DD, breast fed 2 kids, and I'm still not pointing at my toes. I'm also not pointing at the ceiling, but come on, they're like fleshy grapefruits attached to my chest wall... I don't remember them ever pointing up lol.
11/01/2012
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by Gracie
It is my understanding that the most damage/stretching is done during the pregnancy. Breastfeeding is the healthiest way of feeding infants! It is the primary purpose of breasts! While it may not work out for every mother and child it should be ... more
I feel the same way. And good to know that it lowers cancer risks! Thanks
11/01/2012
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by deltalima
Haha good one.
Thanks lol
11/01/2012
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by travelnurse
pumping verses feeding doesn't matter and breast tissue with stretch with age anyway. The pumping is the same action as the child sucking. I breast fed 2 boys for years and it really isn't any different. My son is 21 years old and he has ... more
I feel that's the best way to go too. Boyfriend will get used to it when the time comes
11/01/2012
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by Jesyra
There is a shot (I believe) that you can get to stop the milk glands from producing, but breasts are made to feed babies. That's why we have them. The experience is amazing, and regardless of your choice you're still going to have to deal ... more
Haha yeah. Its Eden fantasies there's no such thing as tmi
11/01/2012
Contributor: The Majikat The Majikat
I could never give up breastfeeding
11/03/2012
Contributor: naturegirl naturegirl
As a breastfeeding advisor for my local health authority I am almost duty bound to tell you to breastfeed! But I am not a member of the "breastapo", in the end it is your personal choice.
Your boobs will become larger as your endocrine system prepares you for motherhood, if you did not breastfeed you would quickly stop producing milk and your boobs will return to something close to their original shape.
But think less about what your body looks like and consider what breastfeeding will give your infant. Your baby has a blueprint when born, breastfeeding is part of that blueprint, the instinct to suckle is unbelievably powerful because your baby's needs are met by being at the breast. Your antibodies are passed on to your baby when you breastfeed, antibodies that could well be a life saver. Your baby's digestive tract is geared up for breast milk, formula will not harm your baby, but it will never provide all the nutritional requirements, formula does not (and never will be able to) contain colostrum. Breastmilk comes in two parts, the colostrum is contained in the "foremilk", the second portion of your milk then provides the quenching element your baby needs.
I have breastfed both my sons, look at my photo in my avatar, I'm 55 and my breasts are still as perky and firm as they were before I became pregnant! In fact I used to be a 32AA I am now a 36B.
If your reasons for choosing not to breastfeed are based on what you fear it will do to your body, you will never know just how beautiful it can feel to have your infant at your breasts. If your reasons are down to an inability to breastfeed, then so be it, formula will be a good substitute.
But if you have any problems or doubts, speak to a doula or midwife (do you have the NCT in your country?), Just please give a good try before giving in.
Lecture over!
11/03/2012
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by naturegirl
As a breastfeeding advisor for my local health authority I am almost duty bound to tell you to breastfeed! But I am not a member of the "breastapo", in the end it is your personal choice.
Your boobs will become larger as your endocrine ... more
Thank you (: I am totally for breastfeeding too, but I mostly just put this up as a curiosity in my boyfriends opinion. We have talked about it, and he really is for breastfeeding. I guess I just misunderstood his point when he first mentioned that he would miss my boobs to much. What a relief, he was kidding for the most part.
01/11/2013
Contributor: EnChAnTiNg EnChAnTiNg
I have 2 children. I tried breast feeding, but it did not go as planned, so I formula fed. Even with not breastfeeding I lost a full cup size. My children are older now, and the breast change has been permanent. Neither my husband nor myself are bothered by the smaller size, by I'm sure some woman and their significant others would be. No matter what you decide to do, your breasts are going to change. Some women gain size and some women lose size.
01/11/2013
Contributor: kaykay0427 kaykay0427
I breast fed my son until he was 9 months old. he used the right breast more than the left, so the left one eventually stopped working and the right one kept going, so now the right one is more saggy than the left. But I highly recommend breast feeding for your child's health. My son has only gotten a small cold once since he was born and he is now 2 years old. Even if you don't breast feed you will have to pump just to release some pressure or you will be in serious pain from engorging. do whats best for the baby!
01/14/2013
Contributor: ginnyluvspotter ginnyluvspotter
I have breastfed all of my kids and I have been told every lie there is and found out the truth. It does not help you lose weight unless you are the type to lose it easy. It is better for your child and should be done. Doing this will make your breast sag but in the end it really it worth it. My family is bad when it comes to being sick and almost everyone in my family never breastfed. I choose to do this and seen that my boys have not been sick nearly ad much as any other baby in my family. My youngest who I breastfed the longest didn't get sick until he was just shy of a year. He has only been sick maybe twice since and he is 4 now. Pumping is not best since you can dry up faster and not be able to fed your child with breast milk. Breastfeeding will also make your nibble a lot bigger mine got 3 times bigger. But in the end it is better.
01/14/2013
Contributor: P'Gell P'Gell
I'm a nurse and a Board Certified Lactation Consultant. I tell no lies. I know about breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding is an amazing thing to do for your child and for yourself and for your entire family and the community.

I would seriously doubt the wisdom (?) of a man who thinks "perky boobs" are more important than a healthier child, a child with a higher IQ, a better immune system, a system of feeding that decreases YOUR risk of breast, uterine, ovarian and other cancers, decreases the risk of SIDS in your baby, reduces the risk of at least 20 cancers in your child even into adulthood!

Also breastfeeding does NOT cause "sagging boobs!" PREGNANCY causes the breakdown of elastic tissue in the breast, NOT breastfeeding. Sagging is also genetic, so many women who have never been pregnant and/or have never breastfed will get sagging boobs, while many women who nurse all of their kids for 3 years will stay fairly firm!

I have 3 kids, all breastfed, I'm.... over 35 years old... do these look all that saggy? (Those are mine, now!)

I have about 8 years of breastfeeding under my belt. My youngest nursed for 4 years, my middle one about 2+ and my oldest about a year and a half. I still have fairly firm breasts, yeah, they are farther south than they were when I was 19, but they would be if I had no children, or had damaged them by letting them get overengorged by not nursing. In fact, you actually do MORE damage to your breasts by NOT nursing after a pregnancy, than if you just give the baby what he or she needs and nurse the baby!

(Yes, some women can't breastfeed, but the vast majority of women can and do. More than 95% of the people on this planet were breastfed. Lets just assume most of their fathers weren't uninformed and selfish as this boy/man who doesn't want his child to have THE BEST seems to be.) In fact the actual percentage of women who physically can't breastfeed is about 1% of 1% of the population, or about one in 1000 to one in 2000 women. Chances are you CAN, and if you can, you definitely should. It isn't a decision like "What nursery theme should we have?" or "Should we do a belly cast or not?" It is a decision that can have lifelong impact on YOU and your child.

Get the book, The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding and MAKE your boyfriend read it, or read it to him, every word! This is one of the most brutally HONEST books in all baby rearing literature. Also, get a copy of The Baby Book by Sears and Sears and read the chapters on Infant Feeding to this boy. If he still doesn't want you to breastfeed, I'd rethink his real maturity and where his priorities are. WHO wouldn't want their child breastfed? I don't get it. My Man wanted the healthiest, happiest baby with the most optimal infancy available. Yes, they'd still be happy if they aren't breastfed, but it's SO much better, immune wise, bonding wise, GI development wise, intellectual development wise, that if you are one of the 1,999 women out of 2,000 who CAN breastfeed WHY would you not do it?

Also, please visit these websites

La Leche League

Kelly Mom Breastfeeding

Dr. Sears and family child rearing website

Good luck. Good men WANT what is BEST for their children. Not only is your BF WRONG about breastfeeding causing sagging because it doesn't, even if it did, he would sacrifice the BEST thing for a baby, so he could play with perky titties for a few more years?


Wow.
01/15/2013
Contributor: Trysexual Trysexual
Quote:
Originally posted by P'Gell
I'm a nurse and a Board Certified Lactation Consultant. I tell no lies. I know about breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding is an amazing thing to do for your child and for yourself and for your entire family and the community.

I would ... more
Great post
01/15/2013
Contributor: BrittaniMaree BrittaniMaree
I have 2 boys and I breastfed both for a little over a year each. It was easy for me I enjoined it the bond you have is incredible and my husband loved it to it brought us closer together too. but I am not gonna lie my boobs have changed a lot after I am sure it is due to weight gain and loss I have done both a lot. I now am 26 and want a boob job badly. I do not regret breast feeding at all whatsoever but wish my boobs looked a lot fuller then they do now. but breast feeding your child is highly recommended by me. It is a great experience in my life that I love and miss doing the bond is so great seeing your beautiful baby, holding your beautiful baby and knowing that your doing the best you can is most important. I remember seeing them look up at me in the middle and smile or rub me while feeding the look of the love for you in those eyes are priceless and unforgettable.
01/15/2013
Contributor: BrittaniMaree BrittaniMaree
Also I don't want formula using people to get upset about my post so just wanted to say not all moms can breastfeed I was lucky to have had that chance to breastfeed both my kids. I don't want any feelings hurt whatsoever.
01/15/2013
Contributor: P'Gell P'Gell
Quote:
Originally posted by Trysexual
Great post
Thanks, sweetie.

Breastfeeding and helping breastfeeding women and their babies and families is my career and my passion.
01/15/2013
Contributor: Nora Nora
Quote:
Originally posted by hmb12
I need opinions from mothers who have breastfed and mothers who have chosen not to breastfeed. My boyfriend says he hopes I never breastfeed because I will lose my perky boobs. My problem with this is that I am under the impression that you still ... more
Honestly, who gives a rip what your boobs will look like? If you "need" perky boobs after kids, get a boob job!
01/15/2013
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by EnChAnTiNg
I have 2 children. I tried breast feeding, but it did not go as planned, so I formula fed. Even with not breastfeeding I lost a full cup size. My children are older now, and the breast change has been permanent. Neither my husband nor myself are ... more
Hmm. That's interesting. Thanks for the info.
01/15/2013
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by P'Gell
I'm a nurse and a Board Certified Lactation Consultant. I tell no lies. I know about breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding is an amazing thing to do for your child and for yourself and for your entire family and the community.

I would ... more
I find this to be offensive. I'm aware that I didn't clarify in the original post, but I have since added that it was a joke my boyfriend made when we were discussing reasons we should be careful about using contraception. We are only 20 and don't want kids yet. He said that I don't want to get saggy boobs to soon, and it led us to a conversation about how those things work. More of a curiousity. We both had different ideas of what happen to a woman's boobs after breastfeeding versus pumping, and came here where we thought we would get some constructive dialogue from mothers.

Fortunately we are pleased with most of the comments! Thanks everyone! Next time I will be more specific I guess, but I was trying to get straight to the point. I will admit that my use of the word "never" in describing my boyfriends stance on breastfeeding was hasty and misleading, but that's why this whole thread is available, so that you can read up to the most current updates.

Lets be a supportive community! Everyone is different, and no matter what somebody believes we can all benefit from trying to be tolerant!
01/15/2013
Contributor: hmb12 hmb12
Quote:
Originally posted by P'Gell
I'm a nurse and a Board Certified Lactation Consultant. I tell no lies. I know about breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding is an amazing thing to do for your child and for yourself and for your entire family and the community.

I would ... more
I'd also like to say, I don't mean to offend you in any way, just standing up for my boyfriend. I feel a bit bad for making him seem terrible, and getting reactions like this, but like I said before in response to a previous post, it wasn't something he meant for me to take seriously, and I was aware of that before posting. The fact that my post was semi-sarcastic didn't register as I was typing it, and I apologize to anyone that it bothered.
01/15/2013
Contributor: petlove0311 petlove0311
I am going to breastfeed my children when i have them. I think it's really a personal choice though. If you're that worried about them sagging, you could always get a boob job once your child stops breastfeeding. either way though, they're going to sag as you get older weather you breastfeed or not.
01/15/2013