Which larger dildo do you prefer and why?

Contributor: removedacnt removedacnt 08/24/2009

It's kind of overwhelming picking from among all of these larger dildos. There's length, girth, texture, material & firmness to consider. I would love to get everyones input on these.

Invited: All users.

Discussion Topics

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Contributor: removedacnt removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Lady Marmelade , Xavier7 , mystepmotherisafish , jankit , Taboada , Eva Schwaltz , tickle me pink , CAKES , chantal coopette , switzerland , sexxxkitten , Mikemanz , rihanne
13  (6%)
Sir , trios , SexyySarah , Sera , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , Shellz31 , Selective Sensualist , greatleader , sophie2229 , Crystal1 , guy4guyz420 , REDRUM , leela , Sebmissive , namelesschaos , PersonalAngel , slynch , navigator-d , BadgersRose , LanaBean , Reny , DCorrelle , jay28 , meganthomas , Sex'и'Violence , daniel and frances , 3d3n1 , Ajax , Jon S , RuMaRo34 , TameTemptress , McWombat , Rainbow Boy , The Girl With No Name , Modern^Spank^Anthem , kawigrl , Stinkytofu10 , Dixiemomma , SMichelle , Girly Juice , Rey , eri86 , KrissyNovacaine
43  (20%)
Gunsmoke , ~LaUr3n~ , YoungCouple , ScottA , mllebeauty , ToyGeek , lamira , Bunnycups , kittychilla , chidoll , Ms. Spice , BabyL0ve , kelaaa33wish , sarki , Ghost , Anjulie , DreamWolf , Hallmar82 , SecretKinksters
19  (9%)
Carrie Ann , Alan & Michele , Femme Mystique , Liz2 , deceased , Yoda , Kaijah , Darling Dove , Raven , qwertys191 , Sammi , Airen Wolf , Midway through , *Ashley* , Alicia , ToyTimeTim , Sapphire Pet , Lady Venus , Envy , deltalima , thatonegirl , Miss Naughty Kitty , dv8 , moonlitlilly , ellejay , dhig , C4ss , MeliPixie , potstickers , pinkcupcakes , IndependentlyHappy , buzz , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , cinnie0 , Texaraguan , Miss T , Herper , Solar Ray , Lio , sixfootsex , Awesome , s2 , Kylar , Totogrl , UnknownGirl , CafeSabroso , Kaltir , Adam02viper , toxie m , Drifter86 , chantalgiardina , zracer , Purpleducklings , x cherri , Lolla Munz , LavenderSkies , null , ichwillwaffels , w-o-name , Mseg20 , 0 , Carmb47 , Fernand0 , Lumberman , The Curious Couple , ToyBoy , KaraSutra , Howells , Bishop , cujo467 , Novs , tokensgirl , Jackol , Reyes , Kinky Ella , ichigostrawberry , Dr Anal , toysforall , EvilHomer , Miss Anonymous , Beck , Sarah <3 , Pink Jewel , Bignuf , Toys in Love , ily , M. Roth , carenautilus , leanright69 , Breas , MR Chickhabit , Paladin Fantasys , unfulfilled , kinkykara , Love Perpetua , Neurogasm , domsub1993 , kellyg , SiNn , NaughtyNikkie , Mew , DeliciousSurprise , badk1tty , EdenJP , dezzydezire , Dirminxia , Churga57 , Mr.RightNow , T&A1987 , Stagger13 , Jake'n'bake , Apirka , Dreaus , eeep , ninja250 , Brandonn , voenne , LoveDove , wdanas , BobbiJay , Katelyn , sweetpea12 , Missmarc , Nazaress , Falsepast , GONE! , Nissa Nissa , legna , Lioncub , glasskitten , BiJess , roskat , MK434 , sXeVegan90 , doc , hhh , Vaginas , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , Bethy Cassatt , J5ive , mdnght , ksparkles16 , Creepellah , Tango8976
144  (66%)
Total votes: 219
Poll is open
08/24/2009
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • Anal Sub Hook&Rope Kit for $19.99 Only
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save Extra 30% On The Bigger the Better Kit
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: LiftedUp LiftedUp
To be honest, I don't feel qualified to post my opinions in the polls, as we only have one of these dildos, so I can't really rank it terms of performance or favoritism versus the others. However, we do really enjoy it.

The dildo of the 4 mentioned that we have is the Tantus Silk Large. Typical of tantus, the texture of the silicone in this dildo is great, and being a simple shape with no bumps/ridges/etc... really makes it feel... well... "silk"y smooth. It's great for vaginal or anal penetration, but it's pretty big, so I would never recommend it to a beginner in anal play. If you are experienced in anal play, it goes in fine after a bit of warm up, and is surprisingly comfortable when you are accustomed to it. It works great for strap on play, with plenty of length, and provides a nice "full" feeling. For pegging, it's nice because the dildo is so smooth that it minimizes the feelings of anal friction, and lets you focus better on the actual prostate stimulation and pressure it provides. The curve of this dildo is pretty minimal though, so g-spot and p-spot strap-on play and dildoing work better in some positions than others, but still does work quite well.
08/24/2009
Contributor: deceased deceased
O2 Revolution. Its like a Temperpedic Mattress of a dildo, something you can sink your muscles into.
08/25/2009
Contributor: modler1234 modler1234
I like the 02 Revolution. My girlfriend and I got one about a month ago. It feels great in your hands, mouth, and ass. It really is the best dildo I've ever felt. Its rather large, but if you can manage to get it in it feels great. The full feeling makes me cum really hard really fast.
08/28/2009
Contributor: Triple H Triple H
We don't have any of the dildos mentioned in the poll above, but we both like larger dildos.

My wife really likes BAM and a few toys that are even bigger! She will use these vaginally and really digs the full feeling she gets with them.

While I can just barely handle BAM anally, the toys I like the most are the Vixen Outlaw, John Holmes UR3, or the Tantus Cowboy.

Each feels different and each allows for different types of play. All easily push my "easy button" and really are great to play with.

The Outlaw probably feels the most realistic and is the smallest of the large dildos. With this one, my wife can go to town and behave in a very aggressive manner.

The John Holmes gives one a very full feeling and really hits the P spot! While my wife can't bury this one in me like she does with the Outlaw, I am still surprised how much can get in there. ;-)

With both the Outlaw and John Holmes, my wife can use her harness and be hands free.

The Cowboy is super slick and the fact that it is very long and gradually gets wider and wider allows for a really deep and wide sensation at the same time. When it is almost fully inserted, it is really hard to describe the feeling of something so deep (almost 14") and wide (almost 9" around).
08/31/2009
Contributor: ref2169 ref2169
i crave huge cocks and for me there is nothing better than the john holmes realistic dildo. it fills me up so good and its really hot to try and fit him inside of you. he makes me cum every single time.
10/04/2009
Contributor: Sir Sir
As a prosthetic, I would buy the Johnny (obviously). He's beautiful. I've been wanting to get him for a while now.
10/04/2009
Contributor: njoy njoy
Quote:
Originally posted by LiftedUp
To be honest, I don't feel qualified to post my opinions in the polls, as we only have one of these dildos, so I can't really rank it terms of performance or favoritism versus the others. However, we do really enjoy it.

The dildo of ... more
i dont want to cast vote bkoz you dont have one that i like you must see this link before casting vote.link
03/09/2010
Contributor: Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
We don't have all of these - but we do have the Tiger and O2 Revolution. We've had the Tiger longer and it's definitely a favorite - but we don't consider it 'large' - for my wife it's perfect!

On the other hand the O2 is definitely large - and it's the best choice we have in that category. The other contenders that we have are the Tantus Maverick - too smooth and too straight and the Basix 7.5" w/suction cup. It's actually a great toy - size wise - but because of it's construction we have to use a condom - not convenient.

The O2 is a great large dildo!
03/09/2010
Contributor: Sammi Sammi
I only have the large silk, but I think I would like the O2
03/09/2010
Contributor: *Ashley* *Ashley*
I don’t have any of these, but I'd like to give the O2 Revolution a go. Its safe for your body, big, and I've only seen great reviews on it.
07/20/2010
Contributor: SexyySarah SexyySarah
I don't have any of these, but looking at them I think I would prefer Johnny! Because he looks girthy and is most realistic, I'm currently on a realistic kick right now!
07/20/2010
Contributor: YoungCouple YoungCouple
Tiger looks like it has a fun texture!
07/21/2010
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by YoungCouple
Tiger looks like it has a fun texture!
It (Tiger) does - feels great vaginally or anally.
07/21/2010
Contributor: XXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXX
I like Johnny
07/31/2010
Contributor: Envy Envy
I would love to try the O2.....
07/31/2010
Contributor: removedacnt removedacnt
I actually have 3 of the 4 now. The O2 is awesome and probably my favorite large dildo. The Tiger is great especially if I'm in the mood for all that texture. The Large Silk I don't use very often but it is nice for a larger anal toy. And the Johnny, I'm still trying to decide if I want to get it. Possibly in the new Vixskin version.
07/31/2010
Contributor: Shellz31 Shellz31
I presonally like Johnny because I like my dildos to be as realistic as possible.
10/04/2010
Contributor: lamira lamira
I haven't tried any of those dildos, but I would go with the Tiger, because I love the material, silicone, and I think I'd really enjoy the texture of it.
11/22/2010
Contributor: sophie2229 sophie2229
Vixskin Johnny Vixskin Johnny!
11/22/2010
Contributor: Bunnycups Bunnycups
I don't own any of these, but I voted for the Tiger because I really want it in red.
12/04/2010
Contributor: IndependentlyHappy IndependentlyHappy
It's a tossup between two of them, since I have had my eye on the O2 Revolution for a long time and have recently considered getting the VixSkin Johnny. Both of them look so good, albeit in different ways since the toys are very different types of silicone in terms of firmness. Hopefully I'll get around to both at some point!
01/20/2011
Contributor: Xavier7 Xavier7
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
I'd have to go with the Silk Large.
01/29/2011
Contributor: Crystal1 Crystal1
I voted for Johnny, it's just more appealing to me. I can't put my finger on why, since I'm not usually a huge fan of realistic.
01/30/2011
Contributor: Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Crystal1
I voted for Johnny, it's just more appealing to me. I can't put my finger on why, since I'm not usually a huge fan of realistic.
If you go with Johnny - get the newer VixSkin version - it's softer - very comfortable for such a large size.
03/03/2011
Contributor: Kaltir Kaltir
The O2 is the only one here that looks appealing to me.
03/08/2011
Contributor: PersonalAngel PersonalAngel
Johnny is the only big toy I would try since its softer and doesnt feel as big
03/17/2011
Contributor: jankit jankit
The Silk Large is great for the price and for all of the reasons listed above by others. However, I love Tantus toys and have heard such great reviews of the O2 line. Had it been available at the time I got my Silk, I would have gotten something O2 instead.
03/17/2011
Contributor: Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
We don't have all of these - but we do have the Tiger and O2 Revolution. We've had the Tiger longer and it's definitely a favorite - but we don't consider it 'large' - for my wife it's perfect!

On the other hand the ... more
We've added the VixSkin Johnny to our collection - it's now her favorite.
03/23/2011
Contributor: LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
O2 Revolution looks great
03/24/2011
Contributor: ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
It is rather expensive, but the 02 looks nice to me and I am a fan of anything that comes in purple. I prefer the design of it as well though.
03/24/2011
Contributor: w-o-name w-o-name
02 revolution!
04/15/2011
Contributor: kelaaa33wish kelaaa33wish
I like the texture.
05/26/2011
Contributor: tokensgirl tokensgirl
The O2 has some nice looking texture
05/26/2011
Contributor: CAKES CAKES
I like the Silk because it's smooth.
05/26/2011
Contributor: ichigostrawberry ichigostrawberry
I like the O2 revolution.
06/11/2011
Contributor: toysforall toysforall
Agreed, there's a lot of choices to make!!! I would go for the O2
08/26/2011
Contributor: Miss Anonymous Miss Anonymous
O2 Revolution (Purple), but I also really like the silk line dildos. I have the small one. I'm planning on odering the medium and the large.
08/28/2011
Contributor: Pink Jewel Pink Jewel
I want the O2 Revolution!
09/17/2011
Contributor: M. Roth M. Roth
I'm really lusting after that 02 Revolution, although I REALLY like the Cush. It looks perfect to me~
09/25/2011
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
If you're looking at these you should also look at the Maverick from Vixen.
09/26/2011
Contributor: Neurogasm Neurogasm
The O2 Revolution is awesome. It's high-quality and still nice and soft. But with a firm core. my favorite kind of dildo.
10/02/2011
Contributor: 3d3n1 3d3n1
Voted for Johnny because I like Vixskin better than O2.
10/03/2011
Contributor: Eucaly Eucaly
I don't have any of them, but I've been eyeing the Silk Large a lot lately!
10/03/2011
Contributor: RonLee RonLee
The Tantus General.
10/04/2011
Contributor: Dirminxia Dirminxia
O2 is best dildo. I like it a lot because of it's soft firmness.
12/27/2011
Contributor: Mr.RightNow Mr.RightNow
o2
12/28/2011
Contributor: Rawhide Rawhide
Well, that's the regular Johnny you have listed there, so based on that I'd go for the O2 Revolution. But VixSkin Johnny beats all.

These choices are really really different, so I think it comes down to preference. If you like smooth, go with the Silk. If you like texture, go with the Tiger. It's like comparing apples and oranges.
12/29/2011
Contributor: chantal coopette chantal coopette
silk or tiger
01/20/2012
Contributor: Modern^Spank^Anthem Modern^Spank^Anthem
johnny because it's the most realistic look
01/27/2012
Contributor: eeep eeep
I like Johnny for the curve of it, but the Revolution because of the color and material (I have the Cush and love it and do hope to get Revolution too someday).
01/27/2012
Contributor: Brandonn Brandonn
I'm gonna give an O2 Mikey as a gift. Thanks Tuesday for your help.
01/27/2012
Contributor: kawigrl kawigrl
johnny
01/27/2012
Contributor: sweetpea12 sweetpea12
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
The O2 revolution looks incredible plus I love the color and lack of balls.
02/15/2012
Contributor: Stinkytofu10 Stinkytofu10
Johnny is squishy on the outside, firm on the inside, and has a good curve.
02/15/2012
Contributor: Nissa Nissa Nissa Nissa
Quote:
Originally posted by removedacnt
Given all factors which one do you like best or are you most likely to buy?
I'd prolly go for the O2 Revolution
03/06/2012
Contributor: sexxxkitten sexxxkitten
I like the look of the silk large.
08/29/2012
Contributor: glasskitten glasskitten
O2 Revolution, and my decision is based purely on aesthetics!
08/29/2012
Contributor: Mikemanz Mikemanz
got a silk large - lookimg to expand
08/29/2012
Contributor: Rey Rey
Johnny is awesome in all aspects.
size and texture
08/30/2012
Contributor: roskat roskat
O2 just based on the material. I have the Cush and the material is great.
08/30/2012
Contributor: MK434 MK434
I don't have any of these yet but I have thought about getting the O2.
08/30/2012
Contributor: J5ive J5ive
The O2
08/30/2012
Contributor: ksparkles16 ksparkles16
the revolution!
09/01/2012
Contributor: Creepellah Creepellah
I would like to try the O2 Revolution.
06/15/2013