What size butt plugs do you like?

Contributor: Free Free
How large is too large?
01/22/2011
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • Anal Sub Hook&Rope Kit for $28.99 Only
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: GingerAnn GingerAnn
Engaging topic analysis of Butt plugs:

Do you wear an anal plug for yourself (stretching, getting ready for anal play, sensations) or do you use it as a tease and display for your lover?
If you show off your plug, do you wear one's with decorations (tails, gem's, lights..etc)?

My First Princess Plug!
I was talked into considering anal toys. Lo and behold, I bought a Princess plug. Can I get some insight on what my first experience will be like? How

Plug for extended use for a beginner
I am looking for a plug that is easy to wear for a longer time, but on the smaller side. I am new to anal toys so i'm up to try anything really, i...

Butterfly nipple clamps
How painful are these clamps?

Looking to be unplugged from the 'wahl'
So I'm in need of some suggestions for a new vibe. My go-to for almost a year now has been the Wahl 2-Speed Massager. There is just something about.
01/22/2011
Contributor: Yoda Yoda
More than 2.25 inches in diameter would be just awful. Even 2 inches is a tight squeeze for me.
01/23/2011
Contributor: namelesschaos namelesschaos
The biggest I've taken so far is a max 2" in diameter. Haven't tried anything larger then that although I probability will someday. I like butt plugs of all size depending on what I'm in the mood for.
01/23/2011
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
It depends on the individual person. My limit for "put it in and go" plugs is about 2" diameter, but I have some very nice ones in the 2.5" range that come out every once and a while when I'm willing to take the time to get them in. As long as you can trust yourself (or your partner, depending on how you play) to not push yourself too hard there isn't really a "too big", just a "not all the way there".

That said it's probably a good idea to use fingers to see how much you can take comfortably. Put on a glove and slide as many fingers as feels comfortable as far in as you can (comfortably), then pull the glove off, put a string around your hand where your anus rested and measure that for max circumference.
01/23/2011
Contributor: Coralbell Coralbell
I like 4 1/2 - 4 3/4" circumference. 5" is a bit too large for me.
01/23/2011
Contributor: Moein Moein
Quote:
Originally posted by Free
How large is too large?
For my partner:
1"-1.1/4" wide
3" long
01/24/2011
Contributor: LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Not above 2 in diameter for me.
01/25/2011
Contributor: thedude thedude
no more than 2'
01/29/2011
Contributor: ihavenipples ihavenipples
I stay under a 2 inch diameter. I prefer about 1.5 inch diameter, around 3 inch insertable length. Softer toys like jelly or really soft silicone, I enjoy larger 1.75 wide x 5 long
01/29/2011
Contributor: Research Research
My maximum is 2.25' diameter right now but I have some larger plugs I'd love to try. They are mostly in the 3' diameter range and I can't even get close right now. It's sort of frustrating.
03/08/2011
Contributor: ScottA ScottA
Quote:
Originally posted by Research
My maximum is 2.25' diameter right now but I have some larger plugs I'd love to try. They are mostly in the 3' diameter range and I can't even get close right now. It's sort of frustrating.
A gradually tapered soft silicone probe that went from about 2" to 3" over 8" of length would be nice.
03/08/2011
Contributor: CafeSabroso CafeSabroso
About 2.25" in diameter is where I max out, in terms of comfort. Slightly bigger is ok on occasion (when I'm in the go big mood), but generally I like to stick with 2-2.25".
03/08/2011
Contributor: Dreaus Dreaus
i can take up to 3.75" on the rare occasion, but for everyday use i stay with the 3.0" ace of spades
03/26/2012