Quote:
Originally posted by
P'Gell
I DO! I'm not being disingenuous. I did NOT know there was a "free toy" program when I joined. I wanted a good Forum (and I got it, I LOVE Eden Forum) and I had written for other sites, with absolutely NO reimbursement.
I love
...
more
I DO! I'm not being disingenuous. I did NOT know there was a "free toy" program when I joined. I wanted a good Forum (and I got it, I LOVE Eden Forum) and I had written for other sites, with absolutely NO reimbursement.
I love to write and I love to express my opinion. I didn't even apply for the Advanced Review program until I was here 2 months and had done 8 reviews. I didn't want to apply until I knew what I was doing.
I think if someone admits the ONLY reason they did a review to get free toys, and they write poor reviews and then attack people who try it help, they ARE a problem. It's abusing the generosity of Eden's program.
I'm getting a little freaked out here. I really thought most of us did this for the love of writing and expressing our opinions. Yeah, the free toys are GREAT (although I haven't cashed in a single of my 8,000 points yet) but it's an addition to being able to reach a number of people with information.
I've done tons of Volunteer work in my life and I see writing reviews, for anybody, as a similar thing. I don't think it's something to laugh about, when someone wants to really help others.
Maybe I'm in the minority, I have no idea. Not that I don't like the toys, but it was never the reason I came to Eden. I didn't even know about it until after I started writing reviews.
less
***WARNING, TEXT WALL AHEAD***
It's okay, P'Gell, I don't think that you or anyone else who is in your position is being disingenuous. Like I said, for me the free toy was the icing and cherry on top of the cake, and awesome, don't get me wrong. But the main spongy, cake part for me is/was writing reviews and letting people know about the toys, and not to mention the great, caring community.
I read that girl's review and her comments as well and I agree with you 100%. The way she spoke, she believed that Eden was a virtual "loot piñata" that would give her all the toys she wanted, as evidenced by this quote:
"...But I'm not going to lie all my friends that told me about Eden is all the free toys you get..."
Which to me, looks like (with better grammar):
"...But I'm not going to lie, all the friends that told me about Eden said it's all the free toys you want..."
She literally flew off the handle when people were actually just trying to help her. There was not a single bit of animosity towards her before she started trying to guilt trip everyone into thinking they had been mean.
Regardless of what anyone thinks ***THAT IS A MAJOR PROBLEM*** we clearly have a person on our hands that, above all else, refuses to see that constructive criticism is trying to help them and shows that we care and want her to improve, and is rude to this community. Even putting aside her thinking that Eden is an aforementioned "loot piñata", it is clear that this is a quite hostile member.
I will show you the first few comments here, since it may not be kosher to outright say who it is, to give you all a better idea of what we're dealing with:
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
1) "Proof reading and grammar checking would do wonders to your review. Try putting it in a word processor and then edit it there prior to submitting here."
2) "This seems like a good review, but it's honestly a bit hard to read. Proofreading would really help it get its fullest potential.
"
3) "I agree with [Comment 1] and [Comment 2]. Also, you may want to read the product specifications, this toy is NOT silicone, it's Jelly, which is a form of PVC. Your review said the toy "had a silicone smell." This could lead people in the wrong direction, as well as the fact that pure medical grade silicone has NO smell.
For many people, materials are one of the most important things in what toys they buy. I won't buy any more jelly toys, and I'd hate to buy a jelly toy, because I was told it was silicone.
Please proofread. Getting into the Mentor Program will really help you write reviews which are well written.
"
4) "Everything I wanted to say has been said.
Proofreading is huge because I had one heck of a time trying to read this. Mentor program, paste it in word, even get a friend to proof read for you if need be."
*** And then her response was this: ***
"LMAO! Wow these two reviews were my very first ever in my life. Talk about harsh and making someone feel really stupid, but you all managed to do it. I seriously didn't think i had to be an English professor to be here but boy was i wrong. But hey thanks for your opinions we all have a right to them. this is so not worth getting free toys for. Just a waste of my time."
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Yep. Not exactly Lady-like behavior if you ask me. She should have accepted the constructive comments with grace and dignity and at least considered them. She may not have broken any rules of Eden, but in my eyes, she's broken rules of etiquette and decency.
/End of Text Wall