Quote:
Originally posted by
Roz W
The title is offensive...because it refers to something that exists? Or because it refers to situations where some people behave offensively?
I agree with a lot of what you're saying, and when people don't respect each other's
...
more
The title is offensive...because it refers to something that exists? Or because it refers to situations where some people behave offensively?
I agree with a lot of what you're saying, and when people don't respect each other's personal lives, that's a problem. I don't think asking the question is offensive.
I guess "recruit" could qualify as oppressive language (it references stereotypes about sexual "deviants"), and if that's what you're talking about, I apologize. It was intended to be tongue-in-cheek.
less
I found it offensive because it is an accusation that is leveled at poly folk who live openly by people who are afraid of anything that challenges what they believe to be right and proper. I am not trying to recruit people or destroy monogamy by being happy in a polyamorous relationship. I do realize, however, that I am in the minority in my belief that both monogamy and polymory are perfectly natural lovestyles for humans.
Also it is very offensive to me when people DO attempt to recruit happily monogamous people to the poly lifestyle. I notice this happening more and more in the pagan community and in the LGBT community. So I wasn't just objecting to the language of the question but also to the idea behind it, if that makes sense. It is reverse discrimination to insist that monogamous people are jealous, insecure and childish. I have found happily monogamous people to be very secure, mature and willing to entertain any notion their partner may have up to sex with another partner. To make a choice with a partner to be monogamous rules out cheating...or at least it should! This is why I always remind people that the struggles we poly folk face are no different than the struggles mono folk face.
I am sorry I wasn't more clear about why I was responding...I never intended to imply that you were meaning to be offensive or oppressive. In an ass-backward way I was actually agreeing with you that the practice of trying to recruit a monogamous partner to polyamory rarely works and can actually be very damaging to them emotionally. You are totally correct that asking the question isn't offensive, if I had found it offensive I would have opened a private dialogue with you to see if I was being unreasonable or whether you were actually meaning something else entirely.
What I meant to say was the IDEA of 'recruiting' people to polyamory is offensive and I misspoke.
The question did catch me off guard but that is because of personal issues I have dealt with in my own life but I should have made it clear that I didn't find your post to be offensive. Thank you for being very gentle in your response when I know you might have felt a bit attacked by mine.