Quote:
Originally posted by
Gunsmoke
I'm ambivalent about the issue. Thousands of years of civilization have marginalized the gay life style. Is there a good reason for it - probably at one time. Dietary laws were meant to keep people healthy in an age before adequate sanitation.
...
more
I'm ambivalent about the issue. Thousands of years of civilization have marginalized the gay life style. Is there a good reason for it - probably at one time. Dietary laws were meant to keep people healthy in an age before adequate sanitation. Are most of those strictures obsolete - yes, but many still follow them.
Has society today advanced enough to declare equivalency between gay and hetero unions - perhaps. To me this is a broader question.
If gay marriage is OK - can anyone explain why polygamy is illegal? Bestiality? Pedophilia? Murder? We justify the murder of the unborn - but penalize a doctor who helps terminally ill patience take their own life.
It's a fallacy that somehow society is 'fair'. Society makes judgments and discriminates in many things. If the measure is 'is anyone harmed' then polygamy and bestiality make the cut - but murder and pedophilia do not.
Society will continue to discriminate - sometimes for valid reasons - sometimes not. The good news is, as long as there are soldiers willing to sacrifice their lives to protect our freedom of speech, we can have this open debate.
Certainly this debate could not occur in China, N Korea, Iran - or in many places that do not share our open society.
less
Sadly the law is often influenced by the constantly changing morals of a population uneducated on the subject which they vote on. I don't really see the big deal behind allowing gay marriage, it's really just fixing our current laws on marriage.
Trying to find where to draw the line on legality of certain issues can be very complicated. I believe that as in your example Polygamy and Bestiality should be legal. The fact that people don't agree with a certain lifestyle is NOT a reason to outlaw it. The law is here to protect and maintain order, not to restrict our life decisions without reason.
Amendment 14 in the US constitution states:
"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."
Is it just me or are the laws against certain freedoms such as gay marriage, bestiality, polygamy, ect unconstitutional?
Being both gay and a Zoophile these issues are very important to me.