I'll share with you some of my most favorite creepypasta and other creepy sorts of things:
link "The Holder Series" is very popular. It's not one of my favorites, but it seems to have plenty of fans!

link "Dragarias Nectar" is semi-connected to the Holders, and this is easily a favorite of mine! It's a "ritual" creepypasta, one of my favorite types

link The SCP foundation is a place where you can get lost for hours. It's full of articles about strange, paranormal artifacts and such. Some of them aren't all that great, but many are really incredibly fascinating to read!

link 200 Phenomena in the City of Calgary is also a favorite of mine. This is full of short entries detailing rituals and other paranormal happenings. Really fascinating!

link the Russian Sleep Experiment creepypasta is an absolute staple of the creepypasta world! It's totally insane, and very very graphic. Be warned (text only, though)

link The Most Annoying Sound In The World is another cool one. There's no sound on the page and no, it doesn't end with a screamer or anything like that, just a story! No need to worry

And last but CERTAINLY not least, CANDLE COVE! link
This is by far my favorite creepypasta ever, and I think everyone needs to read it! GET TO IT!
I don't want to spoil it for you, just GO!! (and of course, don't worry there are no scary pictures or noises or anything, just text!)

So... yes! What do the Edenites think of Creepypasta?

And of course, there's the story of Vox and King Beau.
link
This is a VERY long read. It reads more like... sort of a creepy fairytale almost. It's impressive, to say the least. I think this story deserves an epic movie, and a lot more fanart than it already has!
This is a time consuming one, but well worth it.
It's fascinating, creepy, dramatic and compelling and just awesome!!

Oh, thanks for these! I absolutely love creepypasta.

They really freak me out a lot.
I end up with nightmares and stuff. Thanks for sharing though.

I freaking ADORE Creepypasta. Problem is that I keep coming across the same ones over and over. I'll check out the links you posted!

I'm an absolute "horror masochist." Even if I find myself glancing around nervously and wrapping myself up tight in a blanket with my face barely peeking out, I love scary stuff, and once I get in the mood for it I usually spend several days on the topic. Creepypastas are one of my favorite ways of scaring myself silly! My favorite source, for convenience's sake, is the Creepypasta Wiki. This person also does some nice readings of shorter pastas.

My favorite (and one of the "pop stars" of the creepypasta community) is the Slender Man mythos. So many different takes on it, and most of them are downright terrifying, while at the same time there's enough jokes about Slendy to help keep you calm. I'm very tempted to get the Marble Hornets DVD someday.

A few other favorites are Candle Cove, Ted's Caving Page, NES Godzilla Creepypasta, and In The Mirror.

Special mention to Blueberries. It's not the scariest one I've ever encountered, but it's the only one that ever made me cry, because I was so horrified for the narrator.

Edit: Hahaha! I didn't even realize that you used the term "fear masochist" before I called myself a "horror masochist"! That's pretty funny.