The New Intimacy

Which is better, Homestuck or My Little Pony?

Forum search
Contributor: pestilence pestilence 03/17/2012

Do you prefer the webcomic Homestuck or My Little Pony's latest cartoon, Friendship Is Magic?

Invited: All users.

Discussion Topics

1.
Which is better? (61 posts)
Contributor: pestilence pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
GenderSexplorations , pootpootpoot , FruityCloud , Jake'n'bake , toffee , TrenchcoatHunters , FlightyBroad , solly , Strider
9
KyotoAngel , Anastasia Beaverhousen , Curiouscat , PinkiePie , SexysaurousRex , GONE! , hatman , Nissa Nissa , CoffeeCup , Falsepast , Cherrylane , MistressDandelion , True Pleasures , VelvetDragon , MamaDivine , RomanticGoth , HippieFeet , xOhxSoxScandalousx , hillys , pirkit , pinkpottergirl , LilLostLenore , Feisty , Princess Zelda , hjtee , Gone (LD29) , tortilla , purpledesert , Toy Fiend , padmeamidala , PropertyOfPotter , ChubbyNerd , CaseyDeuce , solly , Strider
35
Nazaress , blacklodge , Ghost , Secret Pleasure , corsetsaurus rex , Missmarc , Kithara , GONE! , plaidvulva , dv8 , hall5885 , SMichelle , Ash1141 , Stinkytofu10 , Incendiaire , improbableomnicide , TheirPet , damnbul12
18
PeaceToTheMiddleEast , SJ88 , BiJess , Master DarkWolf , melissa1973 , DreamWolf , KyotoAngel , leelee , SexysaurousRex , corsetsaurus rex , Various , mpfm , Jon S , Breas , CoffeeCup , unfulfilled , Falsepast , Cherrylane , roskat , Kitka , potstickers , richsam , MamaDivine , RomanticGoth , mmmmm , SMichelle , T&A1987 , booboo111926 , wdanas , Ash1141 , lulz , Rey , namelesschaos , LavenderSkies , Darklyvan , SecondStory , Gone (LD29) , Incendiaire , JoshJosh123 , Kiwi Green , Bignuf , ImportPerv , Entropy , amazon , edeneve , PropertyOfPotter , ChubbyNerd , CaseyDeuce , Cat E. , Hot4You
50
Total votes: 112 (94 voters)
Poll is open
03/17/2012
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • Anal Sub Hook&Rope Kit for $28.99 Only
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Nazaress Nazaress
Currently, neither. I gave up on Homestuck because I was too far behind and it was too frequent for me to catch up and keep up. I've never seen MLP, though I want to. I just don't have the motivation to do, well, pretty much anything. Lol.

EDIT: Also, I'm going to assume you're a Tumblrer. I can sense it.
03/17/2012
Contributor: PeaceToTheMiddleEast PeaceToTheMiddleEast
Never heard of Homestuck and never knew they had a MLP on the web. I would be interested in the MLP.
03/17/2012
Contributor: pestilence pestilence
Quote:
Originally posted by Nazaress
Currently, neither. I gave up on Homestuck because I was too far behind and it was too frequent for me to catch up and keep up. I've never seen MLP, though I want to. I just don't have the motivation to do, well, pretty much anything. ... more
Ahaha, yes, I do have a Tumblr. Though I don't use it as often as some.
03/17/2012
Contributor: Nazaress Nazaress
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Ahaha, yes, I do have a Tumblr. Though I don't use it as often as some.
I just got the Tumblr vibe because you can't go on Tumblr for two seconds without seeing Homestuck and MLP. Lol. I used to go on it quite frequently but now, I'm more of a casual reblogger than anything.
03/17/2012
Contributor: Master DarkWolf Master DarkWolf
What is Homestuck?
03/17/2012
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
I have no idea what Homestuck is...
03/17/2012
Contributor: KyotoAngel KyotoAngel
The one time I googled 'homestuck' I wasn't terribly impressed so I'd have to pick MLP: FiM.
So unless I happen to have screwed up my google search somehow it's an easy choice.
03/17/2012
Contributor: Anastasia Beaverhousen Anastasia Beaverhousen
Both fandoms can be really irritating, but I enjoy MLP.
03/18/2012
Contributor: GenderSexplorations GenderSexplorations
Homestuck! It amuses me so much! Especially the fandom itself and the fanfiction for it. Haven't gotten into MLP: FiM so far. But friends keep nagging me to look into it so I might.
03/18/2012
Contributor: leelee leelee
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
I've never heard of homestuck and only seen my little pony once dont really care for it.
03/19/2012
Contributor: PinkiePie PinkiePie
I'm a pony girl myself. I've tried to get into Homestuck a few times, but I am not a fan, it's not my thing. So My Little Pony it is!
03/19/2012
Contributor: Caus Caus
Neither.
03/19/2012
Contributor: SexysaurousRex SexysaurousRex
my little pony. mostly cause i find its popularity outside the target demographic hilarious. also its actually a well written show.
i'd never even heard of homestuck till last weekend.
03/22/2012
Contributor: corsetsaurus rex corsetsaurus rex
I had my first run-in with the Homestuck fandom at a convention this past weekend. They did not make a great first impression. And I still have no idea what it is, except that there's grey people.
03/22/2012
Contributor: Kithara Kithara
They are both equally good in my opinion. Neither caught my love after a decent amount of exposure to each, but they were both enjoyable enough.
03/23/2012
Contributor: plaidvulva plaidvulva
I like neither.
03/23/2012
Contributor: pootpootpoot pootpootpoot
Homestuck. MLP is just too childish for me. Homestuck can be difficult to get into at first, but the story is very complex and I love how every single detail becomes important later in the story.

Both fandoms have gorgeous fanart, however! Even though I don't personally like MLP I can appreciate the art.
04/01/2012
Contributor: pootpootpoot pootpootpoot
Quote:
Originally posted by Master DarkWolf
What is Homestuck?
Homestuck is an interactive webcomic. The plot gets very complex, but it starts out being about some kids who are playing the beta of a game that is sort of like Sims but in real life (you can control/move around the furniture in your friend's house as opposed to a sim's house). It involves a LOT of reading, and it takes a while for the plot to pick up, and the art is generally nothing special. The fans are known for being largely terrible, but there's a lot of gorgeous fan art. Hope that helps!
04/01/2012
Contributor: hatman hatman
MLP all the way. /bro hoof
04/02/2012
Contributor: Nissa Nissa Nissa Nissa
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
I never really could get into Homestuck, but I love MLP:FIM
04/02/2012
Contributor: FruityCloud FruityCloud
I've never really been able to get into Homestuck, but my guy loves it.
04/02/2012
Contributor: CoffeeCup CoffeeCup
I'm a Brony!
04/02/2012
Contributor: unfulfilled unfulfilled
I have no idea what homestuck is, and haven't watched my little pony either.
04/02/2012
Contributor: Falsepast Falsepast
did you know you are my very best friiiieeennndddsss
04/06/2012
Contributor: True Pleasures True Pleasures
Muffins!
04/13/2012
Contributor: richsam richsam
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
What is Homestuck?
04/20/2012
Contributor: pootpootpoot pootpootpoot
Quote:
Originally posted by richsam
What is Homestuck?
I posted an answer to that in this very thread
04/20/2012
Contributor: RomanticGoth RomanticGoth
04/25/2012
Contributor: KyotoAngel KyotoAngel
Quote:
Originally posted by RomanticGoth
x'3 What a face...he looks like he just won the lottery or something!
04/26/2012
Contributor: mmmmm mmmmm
No idea what Homestuck is.
06/13/2012
Contributor: pootpootpoot pootpootpoot
Quote:
Originally posted by mmmmm
No idea what Homestuck is.
It's explained earlier in this thread
06/14/2012
Contributor: HippieFeet HippieFeet
MLP! I have heard that Homestuck has some juggalo references or something so I've been meaning to watch
06/16/2012
Contributor: xOhxSoxScandalousx xOhxSoxScandalousx
What's Homestuck? lol
06/19/2012
Contributor: hillys hillys
Never heard of homestuck but omg i love my little pony!
06/19/2012
Contributor: pirkit pirkit
I love both, but MLP is better. I'm really behind on Homestuck though so maybe if I caught up it would be different.
06/21/2012
Contributor: symon symon
Homestuck~
07/25/2012
Contributor: Ash1141 Ash1141
Never heard of homestuck
07/25/2012
Contributor: Stinkytofu10 Stinkytofu10
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
Neither.
07/26/2012
Contributor: namelesschaos namelesschaos
Never heard of Homestruck till now but i did let the local bronies convince me to watch MLP and...



I for one welcome our new equestrian overloads.
07/26/2012
Contributor: Darklyvan Darklyvan
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
Homestuck?
07/26/2012
Contributor: LilLostLenore LilLostLenore
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
my lil pony
07/28/2012
Contributor: Feisty Feisty
My Little Pony
07/28/2012
Contributor: hjtee hjtee
My Little Pony, by far!!
07/28/2012
Contributor: toffee toffee
I don't read Homestuck anymore, but I'll always have a soft spot for it!
02/07/2013
Contributor: TrenchcoatHunters TrenchcoatHunters
Quote:
Originally posted by pestilence
Which of the two do you prefer?
Homestuck. Though I've given up on it.
02/08/2013
Contributor: Gone (LD29) Gone (LD29)
What is Homestuck?
02/08/2013
Contributor: JoshJosh123 JoshJosh123
What is this?
02/08/2013
Contributor: Incendiaire Incendiaire
I've never seen either.
02/08/2013
Contributor: tortilla tortilla
little pony
02/08/2013
Contributor: JennSenn JennSenn
I like both. But they both have flaws. Homestuck got a little too game heavy for me recently and I had trouble catching up. I also didn't really get into it until the trolls showed up.

They're very different things though and I'm not into comparing things so different if I don't greatly prefer one over the other.
02/08/2013
Contributor: FlightyBroad FlightyBroad
I don't really see how these can be compared. Homestuck is a non-linear, extremely long and convoluted webcomic, while MLP: FiM is a cartoon meant for young children that happened to garner a completely different audience than expected.
Personally, I enjoy Homestuck more, as the characters are more developed, the story has a lot more going on, and the world building for troll society is extremely fascinating.
However, like I said, they can't really be compared.
02/10/2013
Contributor: improbableomnicide improbableomnicide
I really enjoy both, and have met many wonderful and not so wonderful people through both fandoms. I think they're both excellent, and definitely varied in fanbase.
02/10/2013
Contributor: TheirPet TheirPet
Neither, thanks.
02/10/2013
Contributor: purpledesert purpledesert
I'm a pegusister!
02/10/2013
Contributor: Toy Fiend Toy Fiend
I love my little pony.
02/10/2013
Contributor: Entropy Entropy
Can't say I've seen any.
02/16/2013
Contributor: amazon amazon
Homestuck?
02/16/2013
Contributor: Cat E. Cat E.
I've never heard of Homestuck.
02/16/2013
Contributor: solly solly
What if I like both?
02/16/2013
Contributor: Strider Strider
Quote:
Originally posted by FlightyBroad
I don't really see how these can be compared. Homestuck is a non-linear, extremely long and convoluted webcomic, while MLP: FiM is a cartoon meant for young children that happened to garner a completely different audience than ... more
I was going to say both but this is more actuate to how I feel.
02/17/2013