The New Intimacy

Better Movie?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Lola Park Lola Park
Quote:
Originally posted by Ash1141
Which did you like best?
I liked the original over all, but Johnny Depp as Wonka was a hoot.
01/20/2012
Contributor: Stinkytofu10 Stinkytofu10
Didn't see either.
01/20/2012
Contributor: voenne voenne
I'm really not a fan. I really tried, honestly, but I didn't like either. I would choose having to watch the original over the new one if I had to, though.
01/20/2012
Contributor: averageguyextrodinarypleasure averageguyextrodinarypleasure
Johnny depp was too creepy for me I watched for maybe two mins and that was enough
01/20/2012
Contributor: LAndJ LAndJ
Both have strengths, but I've seen the original too many times.
01/21/2012
Contributor: Ms. N Ms. N
Definitely prefer the original. Gene Wilder was so funny in it. And the Oompa Loompa songs were great
01/21/2012
Contributor: ThoughtsAblaze ThoughtsAblaze
I like Johnny Depp, but I found that movie absurd and somewhat creepy.
01/21/2012
Contributor: kawigrl kawigrl
didn't like either
01/21/2012
Contributor: Breas Breas
The original, but both are good.
01/21/2012
Contributor: Anjulie Anjulie
Quote:
Originally posted by The Curious Couple
Oh man, the original Gene Wilder version was a lot better!
Agreed
01/21/2012
Contributor: rawsonbr rawsonbr
Original, though I'm a die hard Burton lover!
02/14/2012
Contributor: MelSC MelSC
Original for sure. The remake was enjoyable but it had just about every cliche of a Tim Burton movie.
02/14/2012
Contributor: Superbals Superbals
original by far
02/14/2012
Contributor: hjtee hjtee
I find the whole story irritates me.
07/29/2012
Contributor: PeachCandy PeachCandy
Both are good, but I still love the original
07/29/2012
Contributor: TheirPet TheirPet
I'm a huge Johnny Depp fan but I just didn't like his Willy Wonka. It's Gene all the way for me.
07/29/2012
Contributor: BlooJay BlooJay
The original is better.
07/29/2012
Contributor: eri86 eri86
The first was creepy. The remake was creepier.
03/04/2013
Contributor: happywafflez happywafflez
Quote:
Originally posted by Ash1141
Which did you like best?
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (With Gene Wilder)
03/04/2013
Contributor: Sassy Pam Sassy Pam
I don't care for either, but I will say J.D was super creepy in that version.
03/04/2013
Contributor: ththpup ththpup
Gene Wilder is inimitable.
03/04/2013
Contributor: Feisty Feisty
Willy Wonka
03/04/2013
Contributor: Real or memorex Real or memorex
The gene wilder one is the one that I remember better, but neither film stuck with me much.
03/06/2013
Contributor: Falsepast Falsepast
Willy wonka
03/06/2013
Contributor: socceras socceras
The one with Gene Wilder is a classic, but I like them both
03/06/2013
Contributor: socceras socceras
The one with Gene Wilder is a classic, but I like them both
03/06/2013
Contributor: Kirill1171 Kirill1171
Didn't like either
03/07/2013
Contributor: tunacan75 tunacan75
I was probably the only kid who never saw the original...and never saw Wizard of Oz either
03/07/2013
Contributor: LoneOokami LoneOokami
both were good in different ways but I think I like the classic one a bit better
05/26/2013
Contributor: Hummingbird Hummingbird
Gene Wilder played it best in the original version for me.
05/27/2013