My best friend is transgendered and a HUGE buck angel fan! I think that perhaps buck is part of the reason he doesnt feel he needs to go through with bottom surgery to be a complete man. Are bottom surgerys advancing any for f>m?
Below the belt surgey
01/13/2011
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
Quote:
There seem to be a few advancements made in the field of phalloplasties and related surgeries but they don't appear to be anything earth shattering. It is unfortunate, but considering that the medical field can't be bothered to treat transsexuality as a valid medical condition that needs to be treated with psychical and surgical measures, little research and effort has been done to improve these surgeries.
Originally posted by
xgreatlovex
My best friend is transgendered and a HUGE buck angel fan! I think that perhaps buck is part of the reason he doesnt feel he needs to go through with bottom surgery to be a complete man. Are bottom surgerys advancing any for f>m?
01/28/2011
They are, slowly (painfully slow). But no where near as quickly as MTF procedures, or any other medical procedures. I also agree with CntankerousUnagi "considering the med field cant be bothered..."
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure.
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure.
01/28/2011
It's an unfortunate fact that the medical field just hasn't put in much effort. I really think things could improve (options, quality of surgery, prices, etc), but until the medical community is willing to see this as a serious issue, it's going to continue being very, very slow.
06/04/2011
Quote:
I've stood in to observe one of Dr. Raphael's bottom surgeries and a couple of his top surgeries. He specializes in female to male surgeries; he does not even perform male to female surgeries because there are already plenty of surgeons who do them (and male to female surgeries are easier to perform).
Originally posted by
TboyTy
They are, slowly (painfully slow). But no where near as quickly as MTF procedures, or any other medical procedures. I also agree with CntankerousUnagi "considering the med field cant be bothered..."
But there are a few good Doc's ... more
But there are a few good Doc's ... more
They are, slowly (painfully slow). But no where near as quickly as MTF procedures, or any other medical procedures. I also agree with CntankerousUnagi "considering the med field cant be bothered..."
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure. less
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure. less
I can tell you that Dr. Raphael truly is a passionate advocate for transgendered people. Unfortunately, however, the results of his surgeries vary widely from person to person, depending upon how well the person responds to hormones and how large the person's clit is to begin with. Some people's clits barely enlarge at all in response to hormones, so the end result looks childlike. But the main thing is that what the person sees in the mirror post-surgery FINALLY matches how (i.e., the gender) he feels inside; therefore, his patients who come to him are willing to risk having non-penetrating penises than to continue to live with genitalia that does not match their identities. At least the patient can finally urinate standing up as he feels he should be able to do.
One thing I wish to clarify at this point is that I am not advocating or encouraging anyone to seek out surgery. It is a big risk and each person must weigh out those risks to determine if surgery is worth it to him. If a potential female to male patient can attain pleasure from his genitals the way they currently are, I would caution that person to please realize that he will never be able to receive pleasure in that way again. As appealing as it may seem to possibly be able to have a penis that is capable of penetration, please realize that surgery CANNOT guarantee this. This type of surgery, like any surgery, comes with risks, and the outcomes of this type of surgery in particular is especially variable. (It is also incredibly expensive---about $25,000 or thereabout if I am not mistaken.)
Dr. Raphael told me that one patient's clit enlarged enough that he was able to form a very believable adult-sized penis. Several months after surgery, it was even functional as the patient was able to attain erections and have penetrative sex---but that was one particular patient who already had a large clit, which just happened to grow large enough to resemble a penis even before the surgery.
To make the new penis as long as possible post-surgery, Dr. Raphael instructs the patient to manually work with his new penis (with certain types of exercises) to keep the round ligament as elongated as possible as everything heals. (He cuts the round ligament in the groin area during his constructive surgery to use to flesh out and enlarge the girth of the new penis.)
But again, as I've already noted, not everyone's body responds the same way to the same surgery, unfortunately. Not every patient will have a functional penis that he can use for penetration.
I asked Dr. Raphael about other surgeons who use implants. He said there are just too many problems that can occur due to implanted foreign objects, particularly underneath thin, membranous skin. It is more the norm than not for the object to rupture through the skin, putting the patient at undue risk for a very, very serious and life-threatening infection.
I know if Dr. Raphael can think of a better and more effective way to do his surgeries, he will definitely pursue it.
06/04/2011
Quote:
This is of fantastic help. I'm curious as to what you might think in regards to bottom surgery outlook for someone who was born with a micropenis that was 'normalized' to look like female genitalia. That is, an intersex person who has what would amount to a 'clit' that is roughly the size of, say, a large pea, with a shaft roughly an inch long.
Originally posted by
Selective Sensualist
I've stood in to observe one of Dr. Raphael's bottom surgeries and a couple of his top surgeries. He specializes in female to male surgeries; he does not even perform male to female surgeries because there are already plenty of surgeons who
...
more
I've stood in to observe one of Dr. Raphael's bottom surgeries and a couple of his top surgeries. He specializes in female to male surgeries; he does not even perform male to female surgeries because there are already plenty of surgeons who do them (and male to female surgeries are easier to perform).
I can tell you that Dr. Raphael truly is a passionate advocate for transgendered people. Unfortunately, however, the results of his surgeries vary widely from person to person, depending upon how well the person responds to hormones and how large the person's clit is to begin with. Some people's clits barely enlarge at all in response to hormones, so the end result looks childlike. But the main thing is that what the person sees in the mirror post-surgery FINALLY matches how (i.e., the gender) he feels inside; therefore, his patients who come to him are willing to risk having non-penetrating penises than to continue to live with genitalia that does not match their identities. At least the patient can finally urinate standing up as he feels he should be able to do.
One thing I wish to clarify at this point is that I am not advocating or encouraging anyone to seek out surgery. It is a big risk and each person must weigh out those risks to determine if surgery is worth it to him. If a potential female to male patient can attain pleasure from his genitals the way they currently are, I would caution that person to please realize that he will never be able to receive pleasure in that way again. As appealing as it may seem to possibly be able to have a penis that is capable of penetration, please realize that surgery CANNOT guarantee this. This type of surgery, like any surgery, comes with risks, and the outcomes of this type of surgery in particular is especially variable. (It is also incredibly expensive---about $25,000 or thereabout if I am not mistaken.)
Dr. Raphael told me that one patient's clit enlarged enough that he was able to form a very believable adult-sized penis. Several months after surgery, it was even functional as the patient was able to attain erections and have penetrative sex---but that was one particular patient who already had a large clit, which just happened to grow large enough to resemble a penis even before the surgery.
To make the new penis as long as possible post-surgery, Dr. Raphael instructs the patient to manually work with his new penis (with certain types of exercises) to keep the round ligament as elongated as possible as everything heals. (He cuts the round ligament in the groin area during his constructive surgery to use to flesh out and enlarge the girth of the new penis.)
But again, as I've already noted, not everyone's body responds the same way to the same surgery, unfortunately. Not every patient will have a functional penis that he can use for penetration.
I asked Dr. Raphael about other surgeons who use implants. He said there are just too many problems that can occur due to implanted foreign objects, particularly underneath thin, membranous skin. It is more the norm than not for the object to rupture through the skin, putting the patient at undue risk for a very, very serious and life-threatening infection.
I know if Dr. Raphael can think of a better and more effective way to do his surgeries, he will definitely pursue it. less
I can tell you that Dr. Raphael truly is a passionate advocate for transgendered people. Unfortunately, however, the results of his surgeries vary widely from person to person, depending upon how well the person responds to hormones and how large the person's clit is to begin with. Some people's clits barely enlarge at all in response to hormones, so the end result looks childlike. But the main thing is that what the person sees in the mirror post-surgery FINALLY matches how (i.e., the gender) he feels inside; therefore, his patients who come to him are willing to risk having non-penetrating penises than to continue to live with genitalia that does not match their identities. At least the patient can finally urinate standing up as he feels he should be able to do.
One thing I wish to clarify at this point is that I am not advocating or encouraging anyone to seek out surgery. It is a big risk and each person must weigh out those risks to determine if surgery is worth it to him. If a potential female to male patient can attain pleasure from his genitals the way they currently are, I would caution that person to please realize that he will never be able to receive pleasure in that way again. As appealing as it may seem to possibly be able to have a penis that is capable of penetration, please realize that surgery CANNOT guarantee this. This type of surgery, like any surgery, comes with risks, and the outcomes of this type of surgery in particular is especially variable. (It is also incredibly expensive---about $25,000 or thereabout if I am not mistaken.)
Dr. Raphael told me that one patient's clit enlarged enough that he was able to form a very believable adult-sized penis. Several months after surgery, it was even functional as the patient was able to attain erections and have penetrative sex---but that was one particular patient who already had a large clit, which just happened to grow large enough to resemble a penis even before the surgery.
To make the new penis as long as possible post-surgery, Dr. Raphael instructs the patient to manually work with his new penis (with certain types of exercises) to keep the round ligament as elongated as possible as everything heals. (He cuts the round ligament in the groin area during his constructive surgery to use to flesh out and enlarge the girth of the new penis.)
But again, as I've already noted, not everyone's body responds the same way to the same surgery, unfortunately. Not every patient will have a functional penis that he can use for penetration.
I asked Dr. Raphael about other surgeons who use implants. He said there are just too many problems that can occur due to implanted foreign objects, particularly underneath thin, membranous skin. It is more the norm than not for the object to rupture through the skin, putting the patient at undue risk for a very, very serious and life-threatening infection.
I know if Dr. Raphael can think of a better and more effective way to do his surgeries, he will definitely pursue it. less
I realize this is a bit graphic, but I'm very curious.
06/04/2011
Quote:
I'm not a doctor, so I hesitate to say. When you say "'normalized' to look like female genitalia," does this mean the micropenis was surgically reduced in size? (I'm so hoping NOT!) If no surgery was performed on the micropenis, then it would be much, much easier to work with it.
Originally posted by
That Man from Mars
This is of fantastic help. I'm curious as to what you might think in regards to bottom surgery outlook for someone who was born with a micropenis that was 'normalized' to look like female genitalia. That is, an intersex person who has
...
more
This is of fantastic help. I'm curious as to what you might think in regards to bottom surgery outlook for someone who was born with a micropenis that was 'normalized' to look like female genitalia. That is, an intersex person who has what would amount to a 'clit' that is roughly the size of, say, a large pea, with a shaft roughly an inch long.
I realize this is a bit graphic, but I'm very curious. less
I realize this is a bit graphic, but I'm very curious. less
If the person has normal levels of testosterone for a male, then taking male hormones is unlikely to have much of an effect, I would think. In other words, I am doubting that the micropenis would enlarge much, if any, in response to hormones. But if this person has been placed on female hormones, they would definitely need to be taken off of them. There is a possibility the penis MIGHT enlarge a little bit.
The round ligament that Dr. Raphael uses in his surgeries helps increase the girth. There really is not a whole heck of a lot he can do to increase length, though. (At least there are no known lengthening techniques with which he is comfortable from an ethical standpoint, given the extremely dangerous risks of infection posed by implants; he was pretty emphatic about that.)
I would encourage you to contact Dr. Raphael's office to ask. It's been a couple of years since I've watched his surgeries, and for all I know, he's developed (or is working on developing) a new technique that works better for him! He is certainly an innovative guy. (It's neither here nor there, but he is also a very cheerful and very funny guy, too!)
06/04/2011
Quote:
When I was very small I (like many others) was put through unwanted surgery which is called 'normalization surgery'. My genitals were altered in attempts to make it look like female parts-- ie., butchered. I have been wanting to get things fixed (made male in appearance) my entire life, but given that it's a bit different than that of a transman, I've had a hell of a time finding any information on the subject.
Originally posted by
Selective Sensualist
I'm not a doctor, so I hesitate to say. When you say "'normalized' to look like female genitalia," does this mean the micropenis was surgically reduced in size? (I'm so hoping NOT!) If no surgery was performed on the
...
more
I'm not a doctor, so I hesitate to say. When you say "'normalized' to look like female genitalia," does this mean the micropenis was surgically reduced in size? (I'm so hoping NOT!) If no surgery was performed on the micropenis, then it would be much, much easier to work with it.
If the person has normal levels of testosterone for a male, then taking male hormones is unlikely to have much of an effect, I would think. In other words, I am doubting that the micropenis would enlarge much, if any, in response to hormones. But if this person has been placed on female hormones, they would definitely need to be taken off of them. There is a possibility the penis MIGHT enlarge a little bit.
The round ligament that Dr. Raphael uses in his surgeries helps increase the girth. There really is not a whole heck of a lot he can do to increase length, though. (At least there are no known lengthening techniques with which he is comfortable from an ethical standpoint, given the extremely dangerous risks of infection posed by implants; he was pretty emphatic about that.)
I would encourage you to contact Dr. Raphael's office to ask. It's been a couple of years since I've watched his surgeries, and for all I know, he's developed (or is working on developing) a new technique that works better for him! He is certainly an innovative guy. (It's neither here nor there, but he is also a very cheerful and very funny guy, too!) less
If the person has normal levels of testosterone for a male, then taking male hormones is unlikely to have much of an effect, I would think. In other words, I am doubting that the micropenis would enlarge much, if any, in response to hormones. But if this person has been placed on female hormones, they would definitely need to be taken off of them. There is a possibility the penis MIGHT enlarge a little bit.
The round ligament that Dr. Raphael uses in his surgeries helps increase the girth. There really is not a whole heck of a lot he can do to increase length, though. (At least there are no known lengthening techniques with which he is comfortable from an ethical standpoint, given the extremely dangerous risks of infection posed by implants; he was pretty emphatic about that.)
I would encourage you to contact Dr. Raphael's office to ask. It's been a couple of years since I've watched his surgeries, and for all I know, he's developed (or is working on developing) a new technique that works better for him! He is certainly an innovative guy. (It's neither here nor there, but he is also a very cheerful and very funny guy, too!) less
I'm XXY, so I don't have a great deal of testosterone, but I imagine I have more than an XX individual. I've been told by a number of doctors that it's a risk to put me on hormones as my case is fairly unique and they don't really know how my body would respond.
Do you know where I could contact Dr. Raphael? Is there a website?
I truly appreciate the help, by the way.
06/04/2011
Quote:
Here is his web page on transgendered services (the phone number to his clinic is on the page): link .
Originally posted by
That Man from Mars
When I was very small I (like many others) was put through unwanted surgery which is called 'normalization surgery'. My genitals were altered in attempts to make it look like female parts-- ie., butchered. I have been wanting to get things
...
more
When I was very small I (like many others) was put through unwanted surgery which is called 'normalization surgery'. My genitals were altered in attempts to make it look like female parts-- ie., butchered. I have been wanting to get things fixed (made male in appearance) my entire life, but given that it's a bit different than that of a transman, I've had a hell of a time finding any information on the subject.
I'm XXY, so I don't have a great deal of testosterone, but I imagine I have more than an XX individual. I've been told by a number of doctors that it's a risk to put me on hormones as my case is fairly unique and they don't really know how my body would respond.
Do you know where I could contact Dr. Raphael? Is there a website?
I truly appreciate the help, by the way. less
I'm XXY, so I don't have a great deal of testosterone, but I imagine I have more than an XX individual. I've been told by a number of doctors that it's a risk to put me on hormones as my case is fairly unique and they don't really know how my body would respond.
Do you know where I could contact Dr. Raphael? Is there a website?
I truly appreciate the help, by the way. less
I am a bit alarmed to see that bottom surgery is no longer listed. (I am thinking he used to have that on his web site. But if you hover over the tab that says Procedures and then hover over Transgender, you will not see female to male bottom surgery pop up.) I would call right this very instant, but they are closed, being the weekend (and evening, to boot).
I would definitely check with his office to see. If the receptionist tells you that he no longer performs this surgery, ask her to check with him to see if he would make an exception. He is quite compassionate and might just do so.
He performs several different types of cosmetic procedures, but female-to-male bottom surgery was "his baby" since he brainstormed and developed his own special technique. I know that female-to-male bottom surgery was the most labor-intensive and demanding surgery he performed at the time I shadowed him, so perhaps he just got a bit overwhelmed being one of the few surgeons who performs that surgery . . . (But this is jumping the gun a bit as I do not know for certain that he no longer performs bottom surgery in an official capacity.)
EDIT: Oh, and I forgot to say that I am so very sorry that you were put through surgery as a child to forever change your natural genitalia. I wish you nothing but the best as you seek some way to make the most out of what was done and what was completely out of your control. (((Hugs)))
06/04/2011
just like anything else in life, never push yourself to be something you're not comfortable with.
-
(1)This is unacceptable / Against the Expectations of Conduct
06/25/2011
Quote:
i sure know if the surgery was more advanced i would be off running to get myself a penis! but right now... the science isn’t really where it should be.... as long as your friend is good with where he is right now physically.. i will answer your question with... FtM surgery just is not functional right now.
Originally posted by
xgreatlovex
My best friend is transgendered and a HUGE buck angel fan! I think that perhaps buck is part of the reason he doesnt feel he needs to go through with bottom surgery to be a complete man. Are bottom surgerys advancing any for f>m?
06/28/2011
I wish.
06/28/2011
Quote:
This!
Originally posted by
That Man from Mars
It's an unfortunate fact that the medical field just hasn't put in much effort. I really think things could improve (options, quality of surgery, prices, etc), but until the medical community is willing to see this as a serious issue,
...
more
It's an unfortunate fact that the medical field just hasn't put in much effort. I really think things could improve (options, quality of surgery, prices, etc), but until the medical community is willing to see this as a serious issue, it's going to continue being very, very slow.
less
06/28/2011
I know there are big risks in this surgery like any other surgeries that require reconstruction of any kind. Me being a FTM, I am very much willing to take the risks so I can be complete and be who I truly am.
07/15/2011
Quote:
i know a lot that dont want bottom surgery. as of now i havent found any of the options look real. accept the clitoral release and lengthening.
Originally posted by
xgreatlovex
My best friend is transgendered and a HUGE buck angel fan! I think that perhaps buck is part of the reason he doesnt feel he needs to go through with bottom surgery to be a complete man. Are bottom surgerys advancing any for f>m?
09/12/2011
Quote:
agreed
Originally posted by
TboyTy
They are, slowly (painfully slow). But no where near as quickly as MTF procedures, or any other medical procedures. I also agree with CntankerousUnagi "considering the med field cant be bothered..."
But there are a few good Doc's ... more
But there are a few good Doc's ... more
They are, slowly (painfully slow). But no where near as quickly as MTF procedures, or any other medical procedures. I also agree with CntankerousUnagi "considering the med field cant be bothered..."
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure. less
But there are a few good Doc's out there who are trying. Dr. Raphael recently (a few years ago) pioneered an improvement of sorts on the old meta procedure. less
09/20/2012
I do want bottom surgery eventually. I do wish that the way they looked were better for ftms though. however, dr raphel is a great surgeon and if money was where i needed it to be i would absolutely being going to him
10/21/2012
Total posts: 17
Unique posters: 12